"I can only surmise that the people who originated these
blogs are uneducated about the health risks associated with elemental mercury
or they need to get a job, a life or one or more of the above". So wrote Joseph
M. Jammallo, a member of the environmental consulting firm that cleaned up the
recent liquid-mercury spill at the Silvio
O. Conte
Middle School. Yesterday,
in a pointed letter-to-the-editor of the North
Adams Transcript, Mr. Jammallo scolded bloggers who "provided negative
comments on how the North Adams School Department and city officials reacted
and responded to the release".
I'm not familiar with the blog entries to which Mr. Jammallo
refers (and it certainly seems like local officials did their jobs), so I'd
like to think that I'm about to pose questions instead of criticisms. First,
what's the big deal about mercury? After all, it's present in fish, shellfish,
and compact fluorescent lights (CFLs). Second, where might a 14 year-old boy get
enough mercury to drop a half-dollar sized amount on the floor of his middle
school?
The federal government provides some answers to the first
question (and I'm hoping that CR4ers will have something to say). The second remains a mystery, mainly because local officials remain
tight-lipped pending completion of their investigation. That's not a criticism, Mr. Jammallo. As the old saying goes, "inquiring minds want to know".
What's the Big Deal
About Mercury? Plenty, Says the CPSC!
According to its web site, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety
Commission (CPSC) "is charged with protecting the public from unreasonable
risks of serious injury or death from thousands of types of consumer products
under the agency's jurisdiction." These products include mercury that,
according to the CPSC, some people sprinkle around the house "for religious
reasons". According to CPSC Document #5057, a Web page called "Mercury Vapors
Are Hazardous", mercury poses the following health risks.
"Mercury can cause serious and permanent nerve and kidney
damage. Mercury poisoning (acrodynia) has these symptoms: rapid heartbeat,
sweating, irritability or hostility, withdrawal or shyness, memory loss,
peeling of hands and feet, leg pain, slight hand tremors, difficulty with fine
motor control (such as handwriting), sleeplessness, and headaches. Young
children and children born to women exposed during pregnancy may be especially
sensitive."
As Mr. Jammallo notes in his letter-to-the-editor, "inhalation
is the primary route of exposure to elemental mercury". So, while some local
residents may recall how they once touched mercury and lived to tell about it, inhalation
over prolonged periods of time is the problem. That factor, in combination with
her age, is what explains the hospitalization of the younger sister
of the student who allegedly dumped the mercury after storing it in the
family home.
In the third part of this series, we'll examine the argument
that mercury isn't a big deal because it's in the fish and shellfish that we eat. As for where a 14-year old boy might find enough mercury to
shutdown a school, your guess is as good as mine. The local media has reported that it came from an old farm, but I'm wondering how mercury would be used in an agriculture setting. Any ideas, CR4ers?
Editor's Note: Click here for the next installment in this series. Part 1 and Part 4 are also available.
Resources:
http://www.thetranscript.com/ci_11127429
http://www.thetranscript.com/letters/ci_11194524
http://www.cpsc.gov/about/about.html
http://www.cpsc.gov/cpscpub/pubs/5057.html
---------------------------
Steve Melito
|
Comments rated to be "almost" Good Answers: