Login | Register


The Whiteboard Jungle

The Whiteboard Jungle is the place for conversation and discussion for education, at all levels and in all disciplines, with regard to technology. Its particular focus is on technology in the classroom, including what types of products work well, which ones are cost prohibitive, technology policies in education, and issues that technology creates in the academic world. The Whiteboard Jungle also functions as a place where those in the classroom and those in the field can exchange ideas on how to best serve students by assessing needs and delivering technology-rich instruction.

Entries typically run on Wednesdays, with the occasional exception of some series which will fall two or three days in a row.

Previous in Blog: Are Social Networking Sites a Career Ender for Educators? (Part 1)   Next in Blog: The Ostrich Approach Is Not the Wisest (Teachers & Social Networking - Part 3)
Close

Comments Format:






Close

Subscribe to Discussion:

CR4 allows you to "subscribe" to a discussion
so that you can be notified of new comments to
the discussion via email.

Close

Rating Vote:







Is Social Networking for Educators a Bad Idea? (Part 2)

Posted September 02, 2009 6:01 AM by ShakespeareTheEngineer

After years of avoiding social networks as an occupational hazard, I finally joined one to see if a teacher could participate without being thrust into the role of "The Educator". Could I be just "The Person" instead, and maintain a measure of privacy? Facebook has proven to be an interesting journey.

Students Descend on Fresh Prey

Once I was confident that I had locked the doors on my Facebook account and was displaying only the information I felt comfortable sharing, I went "public" and added friends. Facebook has a feature that combs your e-mail address book for people who are also associated with Facebook accounts.

I had decided long before I joined Facebook that if I ever did try social networking, that I would not add students or players (current or former) as friends. This was difficult in a few cases regarding former students who I now interact with professionally. However, by maintaining uniform standards, I hoped that people would respect my boundaries. And I was put to the test early. Some 17 minutes after going "live" on Facebook, I received my first message from a player who wanted to add me as a friend but wanted to know why the "Add as Friend" button was missing.

Strength in Numbers

As any educator knows, enforcing a socially unpopular rule (like removing hats or keeping cell phones out of sight) is enormously more difficult when a few colleagues willfully ignore enforcement of that rule. So I drew upon numbers in my response to the request. I stated that "we are undertaking the policy that we are not friending students or players, past or current, in order to keep boundaries professional. It is uniform and nothing personal." The pluralization wasn't totally untrue as the coaching staff I worked with decided last year to take that approach for those who had accounts. The student responded that he understood and that after an incident that had cost a teacher a job at his school (I coach his regional team), all of his teachers were giving similar responses. I've had to respond in kind to two other former students, but the add-friend requests ended once word got out.

Going the Way of the Luddite – An Outmoded Ideology

In our digital age, communication and accountability are buzzwords. People expect information to be available when they want it, and hellfire will erupt should they have to wait. I admit that I prefer e-mail to phone calls because I can respond when I have time. Plus, I don't need an empty room to share confidential information (as I would with a phone call). Ten years ago, the teacher who had a website was rare. Now, many post their own podcasts and videos on sites like TeacherTube. Slowly, technology moves into education on the backs, most often, of its youngest teachers.

Social networking may not be for everyone, but it doesn't appear to going away either. Few other professions frown so heavily on social networks, but if common sense prevails and adults establish boundaries early and uniformly, why can't educators enjoy a technology that keeps people connected?

In the first few weeks, Facebook has allowed me to reconnect with both friends and family from all over the country. These are folks I haven't talked to in ages. It's been a fun experience. While I still staunchly avoid Twitter, it's been fun to wake up in the morning and catch up on what some of my friends are up to that day. This isn't like e-mail where each post demands a response. I can just take a peak and comment where and when I want. As long as educators are sensible, Facebook can be a communication tool that doesn't have to impact their career.

Related Readings (please note that hyperlinks will not work until future blogs are posted):

Part 1Are Social Networking Sites a Carreer Ender for Educators?
Part 2Is Social Networking for Educators a Bad Idea? (Part 2)
Part 3The Ostrich Approach Is Not the Wisest (Teachers & Social Networking - Part 3)


Interested in this topic? By joining CR4 you can "subscribe" to
this discussion and receive notification when new comments are added.
Guru
Technical Fields - Technical Writing - New Member

Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Vancleave, Ms about 30 miles inland from Biloxi and the coast
Posts: 674
Good Answers: 22
#1

Re: Is Social Networking for Educators a Bad Idea? (Part 2)

09/25/2009 6:24 PM

Young people in school don't have the maturity needed to responsibly interact with others over face-book and other sites. That being the case, I would outlaw cell phones from school. Educators would have to get their act together also. They need to get back to the "good role model" image so many now lack. Educators need to maintain a comfortable distance between themselves and their students. "Familiarity breeds contempt". There must be a "no-man's-land" separating the educator and student. The "buddy-buddy" attitude doesn't work. Educators must maintain a level of respectability. Without that respect, how do you expect a student to look up to? Educators, should be held to a higher standard like police, government officials and clergy, although that isn't always the case. It may sound old fashioned, but it resulted in better educated kids. I really must emphasize a boundary line between educators and students that neither can cross over. That relationship exists in the workplace and for a very good reason.

__________________
Ron, a Yankee by birth, a Mississippian by choice
Interested in this topic? By joining CR4 you can "subscribe" to
this discussion and receive notification when new comments are added.

Previous in Blog: Are Social Networking Sites a Career Ender for Educators? (Part 1)   Next in Blog: The Ostrich Approach Is Not the Wisest (Teachers & Social Networking - Part 3)
You might be interested in: I/Q Modulators and I/Q Demodulators, Product Training, Fieldbus Products