Can you settle a disagreement for me here? Two Instrument Techs. Two opinions. One of us can't be right. Which is it?
The question is about installing a pressure sensing instrument in a 120# steam line. We both agree that the proper way to do it is to use a pipe connection utilizing a condensation trap (U tube or pigtail) to protect the sensitive instrument from the elevated temperature of the steam. But, in a hypothetical installation where the condensate trap is impractical, my friend claims that simply placing the instrument at the end of about 6 ft of pipe is enough to eliminate the heat transfer problem. The instrument would be too far away from the steam header for the steam to have much effect. This assumes that there will be no low point in the line for condensate to accumulate. In other words, the impulse line is completely vertical from the steam header to the instrument. You may also assume that the impulse line is 1/2" and could be either tubing or pipe.
I, on the other hand, claim that due to the properties of a gas, and the expansion ratio of water to steam, the temperature at the instrument, which is at the tip top of the vertical column of gas, will be very close to that of the steam in the 120# header.
Which one of us is full of hot air?