Engineering360: "Germany ends its nuclear power era"

We can all learn from Germany's experiences with their decisions regarding energy policy.

Can you further explain what you mean by that comment? I can't tell if you are finding fault with their policy. And, if so, what are your concerns? Or, are you in favor of their policy? And why?

I might have you mixed up with another contributor. I thought you were pro-nuclear power. But, please forgive me if I am wrong.

Thank you.

Well, last winter we witnessed what happened in Germany when their supply of Russian gas was interrupted. Fortunately, the winter was uncharacteristically mild and the Germans managed okay but there were some worried people at the start of the winter. I believe it is foolish to not have a diverse energy profile, much the same way financial advisors advocate a diverse investment strategy.

I believe nuclear power is an important component in an energy portfolio as a base load generation source. Or coal plants work well for that function too.

Solar and wind can have their place too, but unfortunately you have to have generation capacity standing by for when the wind don't blow and the sun ain't shining.

It's too bad because nuclear is the best option of providing energy that doesn't contribute much to climate change. And now Germany will be tying to buy more gas and oil from Russia.

Thank you for clarifying. That is what I remember about you from previous posts you made. I am definitely in your boat on this issue. The silver lining is that Germany is a democracy. Therefore, I assume their decision, though maybe not well informed or well thought out, is their decision to make.

This is a policy error of epic proportions.

Good luck coming off of gas & coal without nuclear. Not going to happen, not in the time we need it to at least.