Hello all,
I am interning at a plant down the road from my uni and one of my smaller projects is re-designing a support system for our spot welder. They weld hinges onto different size doors. The current system (below) is not very practical as it does not securely hold the supports. The hand-retractable spring plunger is very loose and there is a lot of unwanted play. (The gloves are to protect workers from sharp edges of sheet metal--easily fixed on new design)

I have tried a simple design like a squat rack from a gym. There were four supports spaced across the front of the table, and it was very sturdy. It didn't work out, however, as it took too much time to adjust them and the supports in the center got in the way of certain size doors.
My biggest problem is getting in the way of these certain sizes. Therefore the supports have to be adjustable from the floor to ~18". I have two ideas so far and wanted to get some feedback on them.
1. Same concept as before with supports on each end, except the support bar and the plate it attaches to would be louvered. That way it will be they will be flush and hopefully any play will be minimized. My concern is actually getting the louvered sections to match up. I'm also worried that it might try to rotate out of the slot once the door is placed on the end. Would this design be possible?
2. Pneumatic system. Would weld some type of support to top of pneumatic cylinder and make it double acting for up/down adjustment. The problem I foresee with this is that in order for the support to go as low as it needs to be the support would have to be bent (think stairstep) in order to have it go low enough. I'm worried that the moment created at the cylinder would be too great with the weight of the doors being offset from the center. I'd estimate the heaviest doors at ~50 lbs.
Any thoughts on these ideas? Also if you have any ideas please discuss. I'm fairly new to this stuff so I would really appreciate any help. 
Thank you!
"Almost" Good Answers: