Previous in Forum: looking for an international order.   Next in Forum: Rendering
Close
Close
Close
5 comments
Rate Comments: Nested
Anonymous Poster

Rare Earths / Lanthanides - Strategic & Critical

04/17/2009 10:37 AM

Strategic and Critical Failure

All of the following statements represent the current status of America's failure to secure, develop and produce primary materials that are classified as "Strategic and Critical" to American Industry and our National Defense.

· Rare Earth Oxides have been classified as "Strategic" and or "Critical" to the Defense of the United States.

· The National Minerals Advisory Board has classified Rare Earths as "Strategic and Critical" as defined under the legislation governing the National Defense Stockpile (NDS).

· The National Academy of Science, the National Academy of Engineering, the National Research Council and the National Academy of Medicine all conclude that Rare Earths are "Critical" to our Nation's industrial interests.

· The United States Geological Survey has listed Rare Earth Oxides as one of 19 minerals or materials that the United States is 100% import dependent upon.

· The United States is primarily dependent on China, who produces approximately 98% of all Rare Earth Oxides, for world consumption.

· China is increasing taxes, export restrictions and imposing VAT penalties on all Chinese exporters of Rare Earth Oxides, Elements and Alloys.

· China has closed many small REO mines and ceased issuing mining permits for the production of Rare Earth Oxides.

· China has imposed strict production quotas and has begun enforcing environmental law on current producers of Rare Earth Oxides.

· Most observers agree that China's current restrictive production, export policy and tax regime on Rare Earth Oxides, Elements and Alloys is designed to restrict global supply outside of China, to lure Rare Earth technology dependent manufacturing facilities into China.

· Asia produces well over 90% of all Refined Rare Earth Elements and Alloys.

· Asia alone consumes over 90% of all Rare Earth Alloys, critical to the production of nearly all modern consumer electronics and many U.S. weapons systems and armor.

· Asia produces +90% of all Rare Earth Magnets, the critical component of electric automobiles (Prius, Volt, etc.) and ultra-capacity electric wind turbines. These REO magnets are also critical to the production of U.S. weapons guidance systems.

· There are no active commercial Heavy Rare Earth Elemental and Alloy production facilities in the United States (or within the Western Hemisphere).

· Our National Defense Industry requires Heavy Rare Earths, not just the light lanthanides.

· Our National Defense Industry actually requires Heavy Rare Earth Elements and Alloys for many applications, not just Rare Earth Oxides.

· America's military contractors are actually 3 steps removed from a secure source of these Strategic and Critical materials, as there are no active Rare Earth mines in the United States, there are no refining capabilities for Heavy Rare Earth Elements in the United States and there are no active Heavy Rare Earth Alloy production capabilities in the United States (or within the Western Hemisphere).

· Published global production and consumption estimates show that Asia alone could consume 100% of world production for many of the Rare Earth Oxides, Elements and Alloys as early as 2015, if no new production comes on line.

· Without a domestic source of Rare Earths, it is fair to say that the United States Defense Industry is primarily dependent upon "China" to sell us Rare Earth oxides.

· Considering the fact that China is the near-exclusive source for Rare Earth Oxides that Japan and others use to produce Rare Earth Elements and Alloys, ultimately the United States is in fact dependent upon "China" for all Refined Elements and Alloys.

· The United States does not maintain a "strategic reserve" of Rare Earth Oxides, Elements or Alloys.

· Our nation's defense contractors are having difficulty procuring these Strategic and Critical materials in the current environment.

· The above listed 'market concentration' potentially constitutes a "significant and unacceptable risk of supply disruption."

· There are no active Rare Earth mines in the United States.

· Consequently, in the event that any Heavy Rare Earth Oxides were mined in the United States these oxides would be sold to an overseas refinery for further elemental or alloy processing.

I am working with Congress and DoD on this issue. I need as many important applications and potential applications for these materials as possible for congress.

Please help me with this National Security Issue. Letters of support, applied technologies, etc.

jimnina9@aol.com

Reply
Interested in this topic? By joining CR4 you can "subscribe" to
this discussion and receive notification when new comments are added.
Power-User

Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: UK S.Northants
Posts: 485
Good Answers: 19
#1

Re: Rare Earths / Lanthanides - Strategic & Critical

04/17/2009 11:37 AM

http://pubs.usgs.gov/fs/2002/fs087-02/

Over the past several years the only domestic source of REE, the mine at Mountain Pass, California, has operated below capacity and only intermittently. Following environmental and regulatory problems with the main wastewater pipeline, the REE separation (solvent extraction) plant was shut down. Mountain Pass currently produces only bastnäsite concentrates and sells separated REE only from stockpiles produced before the shutdown.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rare_earth_element

High Rare Earth prices have wreaked havoc on many rural Chinese villages, as many illegal rare earth mines have been spewing toxic waste into the general water supply.

- This is news to me, but comparing the two paragraphs it would seem to be a messy process and both countries have set about cleaning it up but you have some resources of your own, even though shut down.

What should the letters of support say?

Reply
Anonymous Poster
#2

Re: Rare Earths / Lanthanides - Strategic & Critical

04/17/2009 12:37 PM

Couldn't you have boiled all that down to:

"US industry and military require various rare earth elements, most all of which currently come exclusively from China. Supply and price are subject to their whims, creating a critical situation."

There. Two sentences instead of all that redundant gibberish you wrote.

But more importantly, who are you? Who do you represent? You say you're "working with Congress and the DoD". To what end? In what ways?

You say you need to know important and potential applications for these items - and yet the whole gist of your letter implies that someone has already compiled such a list. Otherwise, how would they know that we face a critical situation?

You want letters of support - and yet you don't explain specifically what it is you want support for! To dig mines in the US? To invade China? What?

Frankly I suspect the original author of this message is a rather foolish youngster (with an AOL e-mail account no less!) who either has delusions of grandeur or - more likely - just want to drum up some new raving paranoia for the masses. Further, I suspect the poster is just one of those folks who mindlessly passes along such garbage for the latter reason.

Reply
Guru
Popular Science - Cosmology - New Member

Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Halcottsville, NY
Posts: 665
Good Answers: 16
#3
In reply to #2

Re: Rare Earths / Lanthanides - Strategic & Critical

04/17/2009 10:29 PM

Yep! Or is looking for points of vunerability to exploit. Sorry if I'm a little paranoid, but I am a Nam Vet, still alive.

__________________
De gustibus non est dispudandum.
Reply
Participant

Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: St. Louis, Missouri
Posts: 1
#4
In reply to #2

Re: Rare Earths / Lanthanides - Strategic & Critical

04/30/2009 12:06 PM

The rare earth issue is much deeper than

"US industry and military require various rare earth elements, most all of which currently come exclusively from China. Supply and price are subject to their whims, creating a critical situation."

The many points make it clear that America has failed at every level.

The larger point is that these elements are critical for leading and next generation technologies and China is able to use its monopoly postion to attract these industrial projects.

The reason for posting is to find people who have a professional interest in the topic.

Fe3O4

Reply
Anonymous Poster
#5

Re: Rare Earths / Lanthanides - Strategic & Critical

05/01/2009 4:07 AM

The good news for me is that I own stock in the only two companies outside of China that will be producing Rare earths in the near term. They are Arafura Resources and Lynas both in Australia.

The bad news for all of us in the west is that due to the current economic situation Arafura had to sell 25% of itself to a Chinese company and Lynas has today announced that it will become 51% owned by a Chinese company. So both companies will shortly be under Chinese control.

If somebody is going to do something to change the situation they had better do so fast.

Rare Earth May Be China's Checkmate

http://www.gwmg.ca/pdf/REE_China_checkmate.pdf

Reply
Reply to Forum Thread 5 comments
Copy to Clipboard

Users who posted comments:

Anonymous Poster (2); Fe3O4 (1); HUX (1); Tippycanoe (1)

Previous in Forum: looking for an international order.   Next in Forum: Rendering

Advertisement