So I cant think of a reason to not use the first circuit. The switched loads are resistive and there is plenty of other stuff going on at the solenoid end of the relays. Will the messy current though the resistance created by the different capacitances switched in at different periods in the AC cycle make this a bad idea?
Figured I'd ask an old timer. The circuit seems to work, but I'd like this box to last.
Many thanks.

vs.
"Almost" Good Answers: