Simaris, DocWin, Ecodial or something else ?

DOCWIN i would vote its more user friendly compred to ecodil is ok but defficult to find for instllation

crm

I agree but what about the functionality and the capabilities of the program ? I think that DocWin is a bit better than ecodial. Any idea about SIMARIS (Siemens) ?

Also is there any software for real time simulation of a LV electrical network ?

thank you for your time

George

I worked with all the three softwares and also softwares like ETAP,Easypower and EDSA.

Ecodial,docwin and Simaris can not be compared with dedicated softwares like ETAP & others....

I would rate DOCwin, Simaris and Ecodial in descending order.

Selecitivity Curves for the individual Acbs, tripping devices will be available only of their make devices like DOCWIN--ABB devices,

Simaris-Siemens

and

ECOdial- MG

These softwares will generate selevity curves only for LT side coordination.

Thanks for the answer ramvinod

I m also interested about a more advanced software, propably like ETAP, Eayspower and EDSA. However I m not sure what best fits in my needs. I m working on low voltage design projects for large office buildings or small industries. A real time simulation of an electrical installation is a feature I really need. I would appreciate any comment on the differences or the target groups between these powerfull softwares

thank you

George

Hi,

In the following link, you can see the study on this tools.

http://engineering.electrical-equipment.org/electrical-software/best-electrical-calculation-software-review.html