Previous in Forum: What Causes Gerotor Pump Flooding?   Next in Forum: coefficient of friction
Close
Close
Close
20 comments
Rate Comments: Nested
Associate

Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Thailand
Posts: 42

Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/12/2009 5:13 PM

Hi,

Can we discuss on as furnished under??

What is the difference between bolt torque and bolt tensioning?

What is the ideal torque value for a bolt?

Does torque depends on material type or size of the bolt?

__________________
You can't save a file naming "Con" - Expert
Register to Reply
User-tagged by 1 user
This discussion was "closed" on 06/08/2009 10:46 AM. No new comments are allowed.

"Almost" Good Answers:

Check out these comments that don't yet have enough votes to be "official" good answers and, if you agree with them, vote them!
Anonymous Poster
#1

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/12/2009 5:18 PM
Register to Reply
Guru

Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: City of Light
Posts: 3943
Good Answers: 183
#2

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/13/2009 10:31 AM

I am a bit surprised you are the one who promised to provide a spec and you want to discuss the basics of bolting technology?

I do not understand your behaviour, if you offer a spec this assumes that you master the subjects you want to discuss

If you want to discuss it means you are not very sure of your knowledge and then how can you provide a spec?

Confusing

Register to Reply
Associate

Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Thailand
Posts: 42
#4
In reply to #2

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/13/2009 12:46 PM

As a matter of fact the basics as termed are not really cleared to anybody in the industry. All the specs have flaw and just wanted to make my spec lil bit better by advises of the forum but..........................

Master doesn't really mean that the learning process has finished my dear friend.

I would not be really honest and would not put this message in " Off Topic"

Apologies!!! :)

Cheers,

Ash Bandy

__________________
You can't save a file naming "Con" - Expert
Register to Reply Score 1 for Off Topic
Guru

Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: City of Light
Posts: 3943
Good Answers: 183
#5
In reply to #4

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/13/2009 4:19 PM

I am sorry to say that again you are wrong.

If you do not "master" the basics you should not consider that all eng. in the industry share same problem. There at least some with an expert level and know what they speak about.

Specs have not always flaws Specs were made at one time for at that time existing conditions and level of knowledge. As you know knowledge does evolute so that some aspects of specs are not any more so valid as it was normal to consider them at their birth day.

Of course one has to learn ALL his life this the fate of engineers as I many times wrote on this forum.

But I dare say again when for you basics are not clear enough, as it seems to be, you take a great risk in writing a spec for a new engineer who will believe every thing you wrote and may be make a big error. Being a "consultant" is a GREAT responsibility do never forget it !

In general I am concerned in bolting with "special" problems which are NOT in an official spec but very complex and some times even very complicated, never the less I did not propose to write the spec since the input was not sufficient.

Please do not take it the wrong way we are on a free forum and I always write what I think and think what I write.

Register to Reply
Associate

Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Thailand
Posts: 42
#6
In reply to #5

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/13/2009 5:30 PM

Thanks for rating me but realyy when I started with comments never thought that I am not really sharing the ideas with technical people. I think its all here quite

Bureaucratic to rate one another individual but surely not the issue being open on the desk.

__________________
You can't save a file naming "Con" - Expert
Register to Reply Score 1 for Off Topic
Guru

Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 2550
Good Answers: 103
#3

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/13/2009 11:13 AM
__________________
Fantastic ideas for a Fantastic World, I make the illogical logical.They put me in cars,they put me in yer tv.They put me in stereos and those little radios you stick in your ears.They even put me in watches, they have teeny gremlins for your watches
Register to Reply
Power-User
Hobbies - CNC - New Member

Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Bronkhorstspruit, Gauteng, South Africa
Posts: 128
Good Answers: 9
#7

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/14/2009 12:53 AM

Your question is more relevant than most people realise.

The two are often taken for granted to be directly related, the higher the torque the higher the tension.

This could be true but in order to hava a reliable relationship between the two it is necessary to have proper lubrication on the nut.

A good quality grease will do the job but a copper or moly type lubricant is better.

If proper lubrication is not used all you measure with the torque wrench is the friction in the screw threads and the mating face of the nut.

The tension in a bolt is of utmost importance especially if temperature differences happen.

A bolt tightened too much in high temperatures may snap when the temperature drops and a bolt tightened at low temperatures might go loose at higher temperatures.

When assembling important items like flanges on high pressure pipelines this may be critical.

On engines the bolts holding the top are usually torqued again after the engine has run at working temperature for some time.

Often you would find manufacturers prescribing that a nut be tightened to a specific torque and then be turned another half turn. This is to compensate for the inaccurate torque reading in the last half turn of the nut as the friction increases rapidly in that part of the operation.

You see that the answer to your question is by far not as simple as it sounds.

In a previous thread I mentioned the importance of lubrication in tightening nuts and some correspondents thought it was crazy as they would prefer a 'dry' nut to prevent it from going loose. The correct way to prevent it from going loose would be to use a spring lock washer or something similar if the nut may be prone to self loosening due to excess vibration.

Lubrication on a nut has other benefits as well like preventing scuffing of the thread, preventing moisture ingress and preventing corrosion of the thread.

__________________
Johan van Niekerk
Register to Reply
Guru

Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 2550
Good Answers: 103
#8
In reply to #7

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/14/2009 1:18 AM

we are all working on the thread in #1 (since both threads are on same topic)

__________________
Fantastic ideas for a Fantastic World, I make the illogical logical.They put me in cars,they put me in yer tv.They put me in stereos and those little radios you stick in your ears.They even put me in watches, they have teeny gremlins for your watches
Register to Reply
Guru

Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: City of Light
Posts: 3943
Good Answers: 183
#9
In reply to #7

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/14/2009 4:25 AM

A bolt tightened too much in high temperatures may snap when the temperature drops and a bolt tightened at low temperatures might go loose at higher temperatures.

Not true In fact it can be exactly the opposite. All depends on the materials used for the bolt and the parts+gasket. In general the parts + gasket have a higher thermal expansion as the bolt which leads to an over load if temperature after tightening increases and to a loose bolt when temperature after tightening decreases. In some new applications bolt are made from Mg alloys so that they have same dilatation as engine perts and are not either over loaded or underloaded by temp changes.

On engines the bolts holding the top are usually torqued again

This is not always -today- any more necessary. It was necessary because of the head gasket behaviour and its set. The design of bolting assemblies did evolute a lot and settings can be compensated by different means.

Often you would find manufacturers prescribing that a nut be tightened to a specific torque and then be turned another half turn. This is to compensate for the inaccurate torque reading in the last half turn of the nut as the friction increases rapidly in that part of the operation.

The reason is not the one you mention. the torque reading are as accurate as possible depending on the torquing tool. The 30°,90° or 180° are recommended as part of the tightening procedure which I already mentioned "torque-angle" and its goal is to reduce the influence of friction on the pre-load of the bolt. The friction increases after the snug fit proportional to the pre-load which is proportional to the angle it is not more rapid since usually the Coeff of friction are quite constant over a threshold in contact pressure of sliding surfaces.

Where you are right is the importance of lubrication

The correct way to prevent it from going loose would be to use a spring lock washer or something similar if the nut may be prone to self loosening due to excess vibration.

Please do not recommend spring washers they are VERY inefficient. there other safeties against loosening much more efficient as the tests done with Junkers machine show.

Register to Reply
Power-User
Hobbies - CNC - New Member

Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Bronkhorstspruit, Gauteng, South Africa
Posts: 128
Good Answers: 9
#10
In reply to #9

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/14/2009 4:32 AM

Thanks for your comments.

You are right of course but I did not try to give the ultimate solution, I merely indicated some of the important factors to keep in mind.

To provide all the answers on this topic could fill several books.

__________________
Johan van Niekerk
Register to Reply
Power-User

Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: India
Posts: 452
#11
In reply to #9

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/14/2009 4:37 AM

Interesting

__________________
thoughts becomes things.
Register to Reply
Associate

Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Thailand
Posts: 42
#12
In reply to #7

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/14/2009 4:38 AM

Agree!!!

Thats the reason why we use molykote or nickel based lubricants. Johan, but the question remain unanswered that why the recommended torques generally 50 to 65% of yield strength.

As I had told earlier, does the degree of tightness is soley based on N2-He leak test and detection of leak as per API 521??

Cheers,

Ash Bandy

__________________
You can't save a file naming "Con" - Expert
Register to Reply
Power-User
Hobbies - CNC - New Member

Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Bronkhorstspruit, Gauteng, South Africa
Posts: 128
Good Answers: 9
#13
In reply to #12

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/14/2009 5:03 AM

I assume that the maximum torque specified for an application will depend on the safety factor for that application. To torque close to the yield point would be unwise.

Once the yield point is reached the tension will either remain constant or get less due to necking of the bolt, untill it eventually fails.

For every application one will have to look at the load variation and the criticality of a failure.

You will not specify the same maximum torque on a bolt for a boiler than for the one holding your front gate.

__________________
Johan van Niekerk
Register to Reply
Power-User
Engineering Fields - Piping Design Engineering - New Member Engineering Fields - Mechanical Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Europe
Posts: 287
Good Answers: 27
#15
In reply to #13

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/14/2009 10:13 AM

Hello Johan,

You seem to be well-versed in bolting technology. Certainly more than many so-called experts which we sometimes encounter on these forums ;-) However, there is one point which I make for the benefit of those who happen to wander upon this particular thread (without viewing the original)

Torque application and any variation of this method (including torque-and-angle) cannot be relied upon to accurately produce the required bolt stress. It is complete folly to assume that one would encounter the same K factor on the actual application as that which was used in the engineer's load calculation. On critical applications this is a very dangerous assumption to make.

Even if the friction factor of the lubrication is indicated, the condition of the threads, the amount of lubrication, the placement of the lubrication, the condition of the seating surfaces, the angularity of the bolt relative to the seat, gasket compression, flange rotation, bolt load transfer and a host of other factors conspire to prove the assumption totally unreasonable. This analogy usually helps to make the point:

Telling somebody that you know how much bolt load will result from a certain torque input is like describing what your soup tastes like before even putting the spoon into your mouth. Certainly, you might have an idea but, without tasting it, you really don't know what the cook actually did this time. Same thing goes for torqued fasteners: You really don't know what the residual bolt load is without measuring it after all of the nuts have been turned.

__________________
Best regards, HeviiGuy
Register to Reply
Guru

Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: City of Light
Posts: 3943
Good Answers: 183
#16
In reply to #15

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/14/2009 10:36 AM

Dear Only One Expert in the world,

There are today due to the evolution piloting of torquing instruments possibilities -you seem not to be aware off- to torque ALL bolts to same pre-load no matter how much friction varies between them. In the application of such an approach measuring at the end is a quality check but not necessary a guide for correction. As you know from your experience accepted tolerances even for highly loaded bolting assies are ±15%. The new method allows a dispersion less 15%. You will understand that for many reasons I cannot explain how it works.

Did you know that NASA made a list of 76 factors influencing the quality of a bolt assy?

You are right ONLY with OLD technologies with which of course one is fully blind. But as you know techniques do evolute!

There is a German proverb I like very much it is : other mothers have also clever kids!

Have a nice day!

Register to Reply Off Topic (Score 5)
Associate

Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Thailand
Posts: 42
#17
In reply to #16

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/19/2009 12:00 AM

Shut up and listen!!!

U and bolt integrity are really naives as far as the subject is concerned. You guys don't have basic idea. What's are the qualifications of you guys, just post it next time I will decide if you guys should be included in my discussions

__________________
You can't save a file naming "Con" - Expert
Register to Reply Score 1 for Off Topic
Guru

Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 2550
Good Answers: 103
#18
In reply to #17

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/19/2009 1:16 AM

Though non-human- let me act moderator between you two (rather three)

Please - this is an open forum- we do not question our abilities/ in-abilities.

We (at least I) discuss matters to the best of my knowledge and try to be helpful to others.

I am not the master of my field, and accept it. Some other (lot of others) know more than me on every subjects.

We can argue- some times I win, some times other(s) do.

No bad bloods - only arguments/

Please remember this is an engineering forum and - practicing the science as applied is what makes us engineers - the application may/ may not be through book knowledge -

James-watt was not definitely first locomotive engineer - but he was- and he was not the ultimate.

Technology - as NN? said evolves - and we come to know through papers/ forums like this.

Let us question ourselves what we are doing is it best or what others are saying is best. If we think we are the better one- we can put on the weak points of others view vs the strength of us- need not fight it out (since here we have time to prepare our argument) un-like live presidential election face-to face debates.

Hope you all make up and enlighten us further instead of fighting.

Thanks and have a good time.

__________________
Fantastic ideas for a Fantastic World, I make the illogical logical.They put me in cars,they put me in yer tv.They put me in stereos and those little radios you stick in your ears.They even put me in watches, they have teeny gremlins for your watches
Register to Reply Score 1 for Good Answer
Associate

Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Thailand
Posts: 42
#20
In reply to #18

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/19/2009 11:20 PM

Thanks, SB!!!

By me saying to write a spec on the subject never meant to undermine anybody in the forum.

My Apologies to the Forum

Cheers,

Ash Bandy

__________________
You can't save a file naming "Con" - Expert
Register to Reply Off Topic (Score 5)
Guru

Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: City of Light
Posts: 3943
Good Answers: 183
#19
In reply to #17

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/19/2009 6:26 AM

The fact that you ask for a qualification is an insult for many of us who have not degrees but a lot of knowledge.

Much more than you seem to have.

I wrote already several times and write it again: the degree does not make the professional, the professional can if wanted win the degree.

Your reaction is not the right one since you do not want to learn and progress.

None of us has the whole knowledge for a such complex problem as bolting, but some have more than others and clever participants read and accept without reluctance what they write.

What I do not accept is the fact that one considers what he knows as "all the knowledge" and is in his declariations "absolute" we have to be more modest and accept what other know.

I am of course naive, I believe that people are civilised and I am very often disappointed.

Have a nice day and enjoy CR4

Register to Reply Off Topic (Score 5)
Guru

Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: City of Light
Posts: 3943
Good Answers: 183
#14
In reply to #12

Re: Bolt Torque and Tensioning

01/14/2009 9:06 AM

If you read the comment I made on this subject you should have the answer you ask for. It is on the other thread.

Register to Reply
Register to Reply 20 comments
This discussion was "closed" on 06/08/2009 10:46 AM. No new comments are allowed.

"Almost" Good Answers:

Check out these comments that don't yet have enough votes to be "official" good answers and, if you agree with them, vote them!
Copy to Clipboard

Users who posted comments:

Anonymous Poster (1); Ash.Bandy (5); BoltIntegrity (1); Johan van Niekerk (3); nick name (6); sandeep lokhande (1); sb (3)

Previous in Forum: What Causes Gerotor Pump Flooding?   Next in Forum: coefficient of friction

Advertisement