It seems to me that a lot of effort has been spent on worrying about the wrong things. And much to my amazement, the lamp recycling industry has taken root based solely on good intentions and nothing more. Truthfully, there is no such thing as "lamp recycling", it is only a disposal service that makes everybody "feel good" as if they are doing something responsible. The crushed components still end up in a landfill. And separating the various metals is highly ineffective.
Now I appreciate that every little bit of effort helps, but at what cost? What are we really getting for our money? Has anybody ever followed the waste stream to verify a benefit? If you do, I believe you will find that it usually ends up as landfill despite all the ridiculous regulations and rules. But it feels good so we all play along anyway.
I am concerned that we will make ourselves so busy with such trivial nonsense about lamp disposal that we will miss the bigger picture. Such is the nature of distraction. And speaking of nature, little if anything is being done to contain the naturally occuring deposits and releases of these same contaminates into our environment.
After all, how can anyone clean up the toxic gas and metals released from a volcano? Oh, and don't talk about the mercury released in fossile fuels! My 4 wheel gas guzzler depends on that stuff!
The big picture involves these last two sources of contamination, yet we are content with fooling ourselves with artificial benefits? It is a little like peeing in the swimming pool while making up rules and regulations and signs about not peeing on the grass.
So I suppose my real question is this. Do you believe that lamp recycling is actually doing us any good?
(Do you still believe in the tooth fairy?)
Comments rated to be Good Answers: