Complete the following sentence: There are no unworthy (or useless, stupid, silly) questions only…….
As I read CR4 blogs and posts on a daily basis, I am intrigued by the diversity of topics that are raised. If I am able to contribute to 10% of the discussions, I feel honored; Almost 90% of the time my knowledge is so limited that I am in awe of those who know the topics thoroughly. This forum is quite an education for me; I often feel like a kid in a candy store and hope others enjoy the same experience!
Today, I have read two interesting posts and suprising discussions they generated that serve to make a larger point. The first post concerns the cause of sonic booms; the second post is a request for information on the manufacture of Nickel Cadmium (NiCad) batteries. Several people replied with good information. And, several people made posts that, in my opinion, harshly judged the value of the questions.
I admit that I, too, had some critical thoughts about the questions and their value. NiCad batteries do not have much of a future and while I am no expert on sonic booms, the subject has received much attention in the past (Living on the east end of New York's Long Island, I was awoken mornings to the twin booms of the Concorde as it approached New York City). There is much information that is readily available via The Engineering Web®.
Still, the fact that these questions were asked in this forum that is dedicated to engineers and technical professionals has meaning. Of note, the question on NiCad batteries asked about the manufacturing process involved but no one addressed that part of the question.
For what it is worth, I believe it much more valuable to ALL CR4 participants that questions be asked with a more thorough presentation of the background and purpose of the question. Providing some context to the question helps us all think more creatively to answer the question and to consider creative application of the subject matter.
- For example, why would anyone want to know about the process to manufacture NiCad batteries? Is there something of value in that process that can be applied to the manufacture of newer batteries?
- Also, why is someone researching sonic booms? Is the knowledge applicable for modeling some other atmospheric disturbance or pressure wave?
One of the most important lessons I learned in college came from a fraternity brother who, based upon a management study he was conducting, offered the observations that engineers are very good at asking questions but often lack the ability to understand the value and importance of issues and opportunities.
My completed sentence: There are no unworthy questions....only opportunities to be realized.
|