Engineering News Blog

Engineering News

Latest news of interest to engineers. Sourced from GlobalSpec's Engineering News

Previous in Blog: How does a jet truck work?   Next in Blog: Ohio considering spaceport deal
Close
Close
Close
7 comments
Rating: Comments: Nested

B.C. discovery may be older than the sun

Posted December 01, 2006 8:10 PM

From The Globe and Mail - Technology News:

Meteorite bolsters theory of how Earth got its evolutionary building blocks

Read the whole article

Reply

Interested in this topic? By joining CR4 you can "subscribe" to
this discussion and receive notification when new comments are added.
Power-User

Join Date: May 2005
Posts: 244
Good Answers: 18
#1

Re: B.C. discovery may be older than the sun

12/04/2006 1:15 PM

Oh, please. How "on earth" they stretch from finding more of the same micro-globules of hydrogen and nitrogen into "evolution" is an exercise in illogical tail-chasing.

There is NO biological residue in these meteorites. They are, however, significant and unusual space rocks; interesting for what they contain, even though it has nothing to do with the origin of life.

Take this dizzy statement from the report: "...the general scientific theory is that compounds that were either already here -- or that arrived on space rocks -- eventually combined and gave rise to a single-celled organism."

Right; and I'm a monkey pounding on a typewriter...that was somehow accidently made by metal falling from the sky so I could accidently type out a Shakespearean play on the paper that accidently formed as the typewriter was evolving. Do these incompetents know anything about the immense complexity of the "single-celled organism" they wheel out every time they talk about the origins of life? Or do they simply figure it has been beat so many times that no one will question the theory any longer, even though science tramples on every assumption each time more is discovered about genomes and cellular functions?

Anyway, the best part of the article is that if you carefully collect and package meteorite fragments when you find them, the capitalist free-market will provide a suitable monetary reward!

__________________
Call it 'half empty' or 'half full' if you must, I've got the other half in a redundant glass...
Reply
The Engineer
Engineering Fields - Engineering Physics - Physics... United States - Member - NY Popular Science - Genetics - Organic Chemistry... Popular Science - Cosmology - New Member Ingeniería en Español - Nuevo Miembro - New Member

Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Albany, New York
Posts: 5060
Good Answers: 129
#2
In reply to #1

Re: B.C. discovery may be older than the sun

12/04/2006 3:48 PM

Evolution is real. Whether or not the materials that formed the earliest life was proteins from Earth or from space is pretty much impossible to determine. As for scientists underestimating the complexity of the single cell, I doubt any scientist takes something that took 3.5 billion years to evolve "for granted".

Reply
Anonymous Poster
#3

Re: B.C. discovery may be older than the sun

12/04/2006 7:22 PM

Evolution is real simply because Evolution means change. This we see every day. However, for life to spontaneously arise out of the "primordial ooze" is so mathmatically impossible and scientifically impossible that why people still want to believe in it and all the surrounding theories shows how poor a job we have done at truly educating people. Maybe it also has to do with how poorly the Bible was translated from Hebrew into English. Since the Hebrew says so much that is very different from the English translations about the creation story, maybe we should look here for some of the answers to the odd beliefs about creation. I've been a student of both science and Biblical studies for years as was my father who has his PhD and there is so much BS on both sides of the "creation arguments" as to make one have a migraine! Roy Blizzard III, Alpha Terra Engineering

Reply
The Engineer
Engineering Fields - Engineering Physics - Physics... United States - Member - NY Popular Science - Genetics - Organic Chemistry... Popular Science - Cosmology - New Member Ingeniería en Español - Nuevo Miembro - New Member

Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Albany, New York
Posts: 5060
Good Answers: 129
#4
In reply to #3

Re: B.C. discovery may be older than the sun

12/05/2006 9:13 AM

You Wrote: "However, for life to spontaneously arise out of the "primordial ooze" is so mathmatically impossible and scientifically impossible"

That's your opinion not a fact, though you say it like a fact. If it was impossible for life to exist within natures framework, we'd all be dead right now. If you don't want to believe in evolution, despite a mountain of evidence supporting it, thats your right. But don't seek to justify your position with false statements you can't possibly back up. Do you have mathematical equations or scientific research to back up your claim of "mathmatically impossible and scientifically impossible"?

Reply
Guru
United Kingdom - Member - Hearts of Oak Popular Science - Paleontology - New Member Engineering Fields - Mechanical Engineering - New Member

Join Date: May 2005
Location: In the Garden
Posts: 3389
Good Answers: 75
#5
In reply to #4

Re: B.C. discovery may be older than the sun

12/05/2006 10:18 AM

We see to be dividing along evolution vs creation lines here. I'm interested to see if these are related to the geographical location within the US (it's less geographically defined in Europe).

Is there any reason that both these theories may not be true, for a given value of true?

To my way of thinking [which is mine, but doesn't have to be yours, and is subject to change, without notice ;o)], evolution is a theory that seeks to explain how we got such a diverse population in the biosphere. It probably isn't perfect, or complete, but it's ok as a working theory - as long as you remember the assumptions and approximations made in its inception and allow for them when interpreting the answers it gives - just like any engineering theory.

Yes, evolution is another word for change - and contrary to what some people say, we do have change in species going on around us...look at drug resistant viruses, myxy-resistant rabbits. Small changes maybe, but we haven't been around, and haven't been recording accurately, for long enough to see large changes - ok I'll wheel out the dinosaurs here...you can follow that line of thought for yourselves.

Creation stories, I feel, set out to explain both the how and the why of us being here - which is why they are found as part of the teachings of any religion or belief structure. They are remarkable similar to each other, and remarkable similar to the theory of evolution - so it appears to me that there is a little of Truth in all of them.

Creation: funny how all the creationists only refer to the Abrahamic creation story (why story? why not theory, or explanation - doesn't our choice of title tell us something?). They completely ignore any other culture's creation myths (don't y'all love semantics?). I'm not discounting or being irreverent to any of the beliefs, but I do not believe they should be taken literally - not least because they are the product of numerous translations and the retelling through generations of oral tradition before they were first written down. Words change their meaning over time. Idioms mean nothing out of culture. In my english bible the phrase "as white as snow" is used - I've been told that this phrase doesn't exist in aramaic or early Hebrew as there was no snow in those areas and times, a different idiom is used to convey the purity of the thing in question, but it would mean nothing to a 21st century reader.

An example:

The boys were gay.

What did you deduce from this sentence? Are the boys happy (pre-1960/70) or disposed to enjoy homosexual relationships (post-1960/70).

So any reading for a creation myth must involve a serious and thoughtful look at what language was used, how that language was used in other extant writings and what words we would use today - and we must factor in what, and how little, we know of the writers' technical and scientific understanding.

The native americans described (so I'm told) trains as steel horses, other "primatives" (I use the word advisedly, no offense intended) have described aeroplanes as metal or silver birds. They don't really think or trains as horses or planes as actual birds - they use the words because the thing has the essence of the word - a bird flies, a plane flies. We civilazados use horsepower to measure engine output, for the same reasons as Native Americans used metal horse - a horse was the major means of transport at the time the loco was invented.

Think of how you try to explain something you don't understand and don't have the vocab for - think of the jargon you've heard that you haven't understood because it's not your field - who remembers the pool balls at the nucleus of an atom? And then stop sniping at the ones on the other side of the evolution/creation debate, and instead try to see where we & they are saying the same thing, just with different words. And when we're saying different things? Look at why, and devise an experiment to answer the question!

And, above all, play nicely. Just because we have different ideas and views doesn't mean we have to fight over them. Debate, yes...insults and more - no need.

<ER puts her thorns away>

__________________
Chaos always wins because it's better organised.
Reply
The Engineer
Engineering Fields - Engineering Physics - Physics... United States - Member - NY Popular Science - Genetics - Organic Chemistry... Popular Science - Cosmology - New Member Ingeniería en Español - Nuevo Miembro - New Member

Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Albany, New York
Posts: 5060
Good Answers: 129
#6
In reply to #5

Re: B.C. discovery may be older than the sun

12/05/2006 10:51 AM

English Rose,

I appreciate your explanations and insights. I agree with just about everything you said. I certainly want to reassure you that I don't take everything in evolution as absolute fact. I'm also not agnostic or atheist, not that I think that sort of thing matters, I feel religion is a personal choice.

If my responses to the creationists seem caustic, or even hostile, it's because we have a rather unique (and frightening) situation here in the US. Up until 25 years ago, scientific research was respected and generally excepted method for figuring out how the world works. Then a creationist campaign was launched to discredit science by introducing doubt into the results. If nothing was certain, nothing could be known for certain, then nothing could be discounted for certain. If the word of God is certain and Science is not, then the word of God wins.

I don't even want to begin to talk about the holes in the logic above, starting with the fact that its not a competition between God and Science, but zealots who insists on literal interpretations of the Bible versus Science. Anyway, you would think this sort of craziness couldn't be bought into by the general public, but it has, to a disturbing degree. It's come the the point where we have debates here as to whether a literal translation of the Bible's creation story should be presented side by side and with equal weight with the theory of evolution in elementary classrooms. This in a country where there is suppose to be a seperation of religon and state.

You correctly noted that the creation story quoted is always the Christian creation story. You never hear the creationists promote the possibility of a Hindu creation story, etc. They don't push for that to be taught in classrooms, even though there are close to as many Hindu's as Christians in the world.

For a long time, scientists in this country kept quiet while attacked, figuring that the nonsense of the attacks would be obvious and people wouldn't take them seriously. Unfortunately, the silence was a huge mistake because now people are under the impression there is a real debate with each side having equal pro's and con's. This is even while they drive SUVs and use microwaves. It's really crazy. Our President himself said, regarding Creationism vs Evolution in the classroom, "Both sides ought to be properly taught . . . so people can understand what the debate is about,".

So I try to respond every time I see a comment regarding creationism. At least on CR4, an engineering forum, I want people to know there is no debate.

Reply
Guru
United Kingdom - Member - Hearts of Oak Popular Science - Paleontology - New Member Engineering Fields - Mechanical Engineering - New Member

Join Date: May 2005
Location: In the Garden
Posts: 3389
Good Answers: 75
#7
In reply to #6

Re: B.C. discovery may be older than the sun

12/06/2006 4:04 AM

Hi Roger,

That wasn't directed especially at you; you weren't the only (and not the first) in this thread to appear to be heading that way. My post was intended to be a short nudge to all involved, but I got the bit between my teeth!

Thanks for the explanation. I was aware that there is a resurgence of "Christian Creationism is the only explanation"; I don't think we over here realise how seriously this point of view is being pushed in the US. We are starting to see the beginnings of the movement reach our schools now - we scientists and engineers should learn from the US experience and stand up now for some rationality. If we don't, we could end up back in the Dark Ages and you and I will be burned as witches!

The rest of this post is aimed at everyone/anyone/no-one in particular.

Whilst we're here and before we get a bunch of irate messages, I'd like to point out that I'm a practicing Christian (of the Church of England variety), so I'm not using the forum to carry out any Christian-bashing. I'm asking for some rationality, tolerance and objectivity. And as I said in the previous post, just because we've worked out how God did something, doesn't mean we've found out why, nor does it imply He doesn't exist. Nor does it mean we actually understand who or what He (or they) is(are). I probably sound like I'm hedging my bets - I'm trying to point out that although I have my beliefs, they are just that, beliefs. They are not facts; they may be truths, but since I can not prove them to you, I can not force you to accept them. I know what I have experienced, I can tell you about it, but to you that is just a story.

We are, I think, seeing a backlash to the "God is dead" attitude that was prevalent through the late 80s and early 90s. What we can do through reasoned debate is prevent the pendulum swinging too far the other way and prevent the damage that that will do.

This is an important debate, and all sides need to be heard. I've probably said enough for the time being, however perhaps we could include the latest "religious belief" that man is totally responsible for the increase in world temperature and that if we all "went back to nature" everything will be wonderful and world peace will result (I'm unclear as to whether that's a pagan idyll or a Christian/Jewish/Muslim Garden of Eden or a an Australian aboriginal Dreamtime or...) as a technical debate.

It is probably true that the majority of CR4 members are engineers, and so subscribe to the "Science is Good" notion. One argument to use against the "Science is Bad" camp is that of the Middle Ages: nothing changed, nothing improved for about 1000 years after the fall of the Roman Empire until the Renaissance. Who ruled the hearts and minds of the people, often using torture and execution and genocide to do so? The Christian Church. It wasn't until this stranglehold was removed that we began to learn about the world; our progress in the last 500-600 years has been exponential. Yes, not all of it was used for the good of everyone; that is the fault of the people using it, not the thing itself. Just as the strangehold on the population by the Church was a product of the power-hungry people involved, not of the teachings of Jesus (personally I blame Paul, but that's a debate for a different forum!!)

As to the first post in this thread, whilst I understand Sandman's frustration at the generalities in the article, it's probaly more a reflection of the article writer's ability to understand than the researchers. I would hope that the researchers regard it as a possibility that is still valid under current knowledge, but is subject to refinement when new knowledge is available.

Thanks for reading my ramblings! [well I am a rose...]

__________________
Chaos always wins because it's better organised.
Reply
Reply to Blog Entry 7 comments
Copy to Clipboard

Users who posted comments:

Anonymous Poster (1); Bayes (3); English Rose (2); Sandman (1)

Previous in Blog: How does a jet truck work?   Next in Blog: Ohio considering spaceport deal

Advertisement