Dear fellow E.E.
Our client consultant opted for a open transition ATS, his reason is as follows;
1. The generator needs time to ramp the critical load. Since downstream we have set of 500KVA UPS and HVAC loads.
2. To avoid a higher Voltage harmonics cause by high generator reactance and harmonic current in the upstream bus. With this, the generator will not be able to take over the load from the battery bank.
However, we need closed transition because of NFPA requirement 110, to have it ready to carry the load in case of maintenance. And if the system compatibility between UPS and generator is correctly design (active filter/or pFC is in placed) so what to afraid of in putting closed transition ATS.
I need expert opinion, thanks
Acer