We are in the process of repairing a coal fired, fire tube boiler which has suffered from burning through the stoker shell and the 2nd / 3rd pass smoke box. The stoker is lined with refractory. The annular space between the outer shell of the stoker and the wall of the firebox was also insulated with refractory and/or 'asbestos' rope. My opinion is that the space should be left as clear as possible to allow air to circulate and remove some of the heat which inevitably comes through the refractory lining. If is insulated externally overheating and oxidation/burning of the metal is more likely to occur again. My problem is persuading others not to 'do what we have always done' and rebuild as it was. What are you views?