I want to make a stainless steel piece of jewelry (constant skin contact) that will double as a hex key or maybe a screwdriver. Most jewelry is made with 316L due to it's hypoallergenic properties. I gather this is due to it's low Ni content and also perhaps Cr. However, 316L is too soft to use as a practical tool of any kind. As I see I have 3 concerns with the choice of material:
1. Biocompatability as it will be in contact with skin for long periods of time: we need low nickel & chromium, if we use 316L as a benchmark that means <14% Ni and <18% Cr with low NI/Cr release over time
2. Strength and Hardness as it needs to be used as a tool: guessing but say we need >45 HRC (Hardness Rockwell C) and >100 Ksi (yield strength)
3. Corrosion resistance for obvious reasons: I assume that we need a high level of corrosion resistance when in contact with skin for long durations. Sweat and other skin excretions can be quite corrosive I think.
My supplier wants to use 420 stainless steel and it certainly satisfies the first 2 categories above but not I fear the third.
Research tells me that 420 has a middling grade of corrosion resistance (only in the hardened or hardened and stress relieved conditions). It is martensitic steel, the LEAST corrosion resistant of the 3 classes. It is a very good choice when a compromise between hardness / durability versus corrosion resistance is needed. It can resist corrosion by the atmosphere, fresh water, mine water, steam, carbonic acid, crude oil, gasoline, perspiration, alcohol, ammonia, mercury, sterilizing solutions, soaps and other similar corrosive media. Notably absent from this list is salt water (sweat).
If you look at medical uses of steel you will see that 420 is only used in surgical and dental instruments and not for cardiological and orthopedic uses, i.e. implants. This tells me that 420 is a great material for something that needs to be hard wearing, corrosion resistant and biocompatible while exposed to human tissue but, at least for the last 2 categories, only necessarily for a short time.
Anyway, I am not married to the 420, can anyone recommend a readily available steel that satisfies all three of these requirements, preferably not a custom blend from a single supplier?
"Almost" Good Answers: