Biomedical Engineering Blog

Biomedical Engineering

The Biomedical Engineering blog is the place for conversation and discussion about topics related to engineering principles of the medical field. Here, you'll find everything from discussions about emerging medical technologies to advances in medical research. The blog's owner, Chelsey H, is a graduate of Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (RPI) with a degree in Biomedical Engineering.

Previous in Blog: Hangover Cures   Next in Blog: Habits of Healthy People
Close
Close
Close
2 comments
Rate Comments: Nested

Living Longer, But Sicker Lives

Posted January 09, 2013 12:00 AM by Chelsey H

Do you know where the healthiest place on Earth is? The answer is Okinawa--Japan's most southern state. It is a chain of 169 islands stretching for more than 1,000km. There is said to be over 400 people living on the island who are over 100 years old. The average life expectancy for a man on the island is 78 and 86 for a woman. This article caught my eye, especially after reading a post about how most people are living longer, but sicker lives. A comprehensive analysis, including 500 papers from authors in 50 countries, was done to review health problems around the world.

Image Credit: Blue Zones

Looking over the results we can see that in 1990, the biggest global health issue was childhood underweight caused by malnutrition, measles, malaria, and other infectious diseases. Now the concern is no longer with children, but with adult aliments such as high blood pressure, tobacco smoking, and alcohol use, which top the charts for the biggest health concerns. But we are living longer; since 1970 the average life expectancy has risen globally in all but eight countries. Currently the global average lifespan for a man is 67.5 (10.5 years less than in Okinawa) and 73.3 (12.7 less) for a woman.

The study also shows that developing countries have made huge strides in public health, curbing diseases such as HIV and malaria, and battling nutritional deficiencies.

This is also demonstrated in the successful fight against childhood diseases and communicable diseases. Deaths in children under five years old have declined almost 60 percent in the past four years. Improvements in sanitation and vaccinations have led to a 42 percent drop in deaths from diarrheal diseases, lower respiratory infections, meningitis, and other common infectious diseases.

Image Credit: Kids Go Global

But it's not all good news. While we've been able to fight against infectious diseases, non-infectious diseases, specifically heart disease and stroke, accounted for two of every three deaths globally in 2010. Diabetes, smoking, alcohol, HIV/AIDS, and malaria have caused an increase in deaths among 15 to 49 year olds over the past 20 years. HIV/AIDs are also still a major concern in sub-Saharan Africa, where life expectancy has declined overall by one to seven years, and young adult deaths have increased by 500 percente since 1970 in certain areas.

Image Credit: Institution for Health Metrics and Evaluation

I'm sure it's no surprise that this study also found that we eat and drink too much, and not of the right things. Alcohol overconsumption is a major problem in countries in Eastern Europe, accounting for almost a quarter of the total disease burden. 3.4 million deaths in 2010 could be linked to obesity and that number is on the rise. Deaths attributable to dietary risk factors and physical inactivity have increased by 50 percent in the past 20 years. "Overall, we're consuming too much sodium, trans fat, processed meat, and sugar-sweetened beverages, and not enough fruits, vegetables, whole grains, nuts, fiber, calcium, and omega-3 fatty acids." In North America and Western Europe, tobacco smoking (and second-hand smoke) is still the top risk factor. This hasn't changed since 1990 and globally it has risen from the third to second leading cause of disease.

So what's the secret to a long, healthy life? According to the Okinawans it's their food and their attitude towards life. They work hard--some in their 80s still work 11 hour days on their farm--but they don't stress. Their diet consists largely of rice, fish, and vegetables. The Okinawans also eat pig ears (low in fat and high in calcium), tofu, bitter gourd (goiya), and sweet potatoes.

Image Credit: Pryoenergen

The people on the island want to live longer to spend time with their children and grandchildren. There is a saying found on the islands, "At 70 you are still a child, at 80 a young man or woman. And if at 90 someone from Heaven invites you over, tell him: 'Just go away, and come back when I am 100.'"

Reply

Interested in this topic? By joining CR4 you can "subscribe" to
this discussion and receive notification when new comments are added.
Guru

Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 573
Good Answers: 5
#1

Re: Living Longer, But Sicker Lives

01/10/2013 1:41 PM

To me, an important subject.

Food choices can be as hotly debated as religion and politics. Vegetarianism vs. a carnivore diet, probably tops the list. And these perspectives get intertwined with both religion/ethics and politics. I know the "China Study" is controversial. (Just check out the back and forth comments for this 1-star review. or this one.) Any one of us may also defend a modicum of "junk food" in our diet, as relatively harmless, depending on which one we may be fond of. Many of us, also, remember what happened to Oprah. (Note it took almost 6 years for a final verdict -- a really speedy process. )

Short of having a complete model of all the processes in the body and a way of tracking them in real time, (some chemicals, such as hormones and enzymes have a very brief lifetime -- eicosanoids, for instance; plus we still haven't identified the majority of proteins in the body), I suspect a lot of data can and will be challenged. The conclusions drawn from observations are still hypothetical in some cases.

BUT... the data that can't be dismissed are the health and death records from culture to culture. And there are some studies that show reversal of disease states, such as heart disease and atherosclerosis, by adhering to the dietary recommendations such as the Okinawa diet and that advocated in the China Study -- largely a vegetarian diet. Explaining (or proving) why people live healthier and/or longer in any culture vs. another, is where the debate happens. Lifestyle is more than diet. And individual exceptions can be found in any culture.

89.2% of the reviews on Amazon for the "China Study" are 4 or 5-star reviews. Yet some of the 1-star reviews are highly critical of the "science" behind the conclusions, with self-identified scientists participating in the critique, supplying counter-study links and references. The dissenting view is sometimes derived from an, ultimately, evolutionary perspective (one reviewer criticized the author for offering little evidence, but his web site seems to offer quite a bit), or from alternative explanations. In the end, if one decides to modify their diet according to these recommendations, "your mileage may vary." I agree with the conclusions, and would advocate a, primarily, plant-based diet, but, obviously, there are those who don't.

So, no posts about the article, yet, may mean -- like the percentage of Amazon reviewers of the China Study -- that, for readers here, it is generally agreed, these dietary recommendations do produce an improvement in health and might prolong one's life. Or, maybe, if they are on the side which disagrees, they'd rather not get into a debate that, currently, can be sustained. (i.e., there are anecdotal exceptions in any setting. The attempt at explaining them only extends the controversy.) OR, few care. That, I doubt. It can be a stressful subject -- especially within family units. And, I think, most would agree that stress can be harmful to your health.

Reply
Guru

Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 573
Good Answers: 5
#2

Re: Living Longer, But Sicker Lives

01/16/2013 3:55 PM

To add some critical analysis to the ideas represented in the Okinawa diet and the China study, without one wading through all the comments on the Amazon links, I just came across this -- "The China Study: A Formal Analysis and Response," by Denise Minger.

I am still strongly in favor of a plant-centered diet. I just thought some might find the article interesting and worth reading.

For anyone researching this topic for other than academic purposes; i.e., for making a personal behavioral choice, I think its ethical issues may ultimately end up playing a significant role in making that choice in addition to physical well-being.

Reply
Reply to Blog Entry 2 comments

Previous in Blog: Hangover Cures   Next in Blog: Habits of Healthy People

Advertisement