I have experience of both butt welding and E.F. welding of polyethelene. In the past we have butt welded our bigger pipes of aprox 250-315mm but now we are about to start a new build and the company is very keen on electrofusion.
They see it as an easy option and because we wont need to hire in a contractor or a butt welding machine they see it as cost cutting.
However I spoke to an "expert" from Norway who strongly advised butt welding saying that E.F. joints don't have the same longevity as butt welds. These pipes once installed, will be in place for at least 25 years. I have seen E.F. joints which were done at least 10 years ago and they seem fine. Is this guy just trying to score a contract or does he have a point?
P.S. The pipes will be layed over ground carrying raw sea water. Temperature range of water about 8 degrees celcius and temperature change of where I am is only about 20 degrees celcius. Pipes will be subject to very little vibration and will be in the order of 100m runs.