|
There is a TOOTH compressor that produces 162 m3/ h oil free air - $55,000.00 - 22 kW.
A scroll compressor produces 48 m3/ h oil free air - 10 kW. $15,500.00
You need 100% air all the time because your production runs on this.
Scrolls are build with separate belt driven units of 3.3 kW, easy to
replace and almost no maintenance. However, to produce the air that I
need 4 pieces ending up with a bill of $62,000.00.
Redundancy means a spare TOOTH compressor: total bill $110,000.00
or Say 3 scroll elements or a spare scroll compressor: total bill $77,500.00
Running 4 scrolls = 40 kW - The Tooth = 30 kW
Question 1:
To use on a island with no big mechanical specialists. What is your vote on this and what is your opinion?
Both type compressors produce 100% clean air. Since the output of the
compressors is at 10 bar (SAD) to atmosphere and the output is blown
into a clean room through power instruments and tools, this will affect
the barometric pressure considerably.
Getting the air also out of the clean room could work as a stabilizer
if the delta t (time) and delta P (average pressure diff.) is kept low.
(as a hint: 48 m3 @10 bar equals 480 nm3 and changes the air 1,5 times
per hour without the Hepa air)
The idea is to have a brain storming discussion on how we (I become
familiar) can avoid aftercoolers to get rid of the water in the air.
Refrigeration cooling is costly and dessicant is polluting (for the air
inside and will be an issue on getting ISO XXXX)
Assume, installing the piping with a run down (and use of CPVC sch80)
You will have no corrosion in the piping and after compression, (and
simultanous water separation,) blown into the atmosphere, the relative
humidity will be much lower than the initial intake air.
This brings the comfort zone up (fictitious re: wet bulb temp.) and
the airco that we need for normal activities will not have to work
overtime to compensate for the heat of the air from the compressor.
(you cool the compressor outside the clean room and only the air runs in and out, Yes Sir)
And yes, (how optimistic we get) the tools need no oil to operate and
can handle the rest of water vapor in under- saturated form.
Question 2:
Am I on or off the track and why?
The deal is one Good Answer for 2 Good answers on topic. Thank You. |
"Almost" Good Answers: