Do groups such as WATCH help children have a safer holiday
season? Or do they simply take the fun out of Christmas? Each year, World
Against Toys Causing Harm (WATCH) publishes its annual "10 Worst Toys" list. Yesterday, The Y Files examined the top three items that WATCH wants Santa
Claus to remove from his workshop. One contained lead paint. The others pose
serious health hazards if used inappropriately.
Today, we'll look at the next four items on WATCH's list.
Editor's Note: Did you miss Part 1 of this series? Then click here.
The Un-fabulous Four
4. Dora the Explorer
Lamp from Funhouse is available at Wal-Mart. Although the
product's packaging warns that "this is an electric lamp – not a toy", WATCH
complains that "the manufacturer's proclamation that the Dora cartoon character
is not a toy has little meaning to small children, who may be attracted to the
figurine." Well, that "attraction" is probably what manufacturer was hoping for!
5. Lil "Giddy Up"
Horse – Sassy Pet Saks from Douglas features contradictory warnings. "A tag on the horse states that it is
sold for newborn babies," the WATCH website explains, "whereas the carrier to
which the horse is attached advises the toy is not intended for children
younger than 18 months old." Would you rather leave the great labeling controversy to the lawyers? Let's look at the toy's components. The horse's small, wooden bead and removable "fiber-like
hair" pose a choking hazard.
6. Spider Man 3 New
Goblin Sword from Hasbro is available at Target. Remarkably,
this toy is billed as "one of the most awesome weapons ever wielded by human hands". (I
guess they haven't seen Del's crossbow!) Still, because this toy is designed for children instead of Green
Berets, WATCH worries about its "potential to cause serious facial and other
impact injuries". The sharpened sticks that imaginary swordsmen used to play with were dangerous, too.
7. Hip Hoppa 'Til You Droppa!, made or
distributed by Spin Master Ltd. And Vivid Imaginations, Ltd., admits that "this
toy should be used with caution since it requires great skill to avoid falls
and collisions". That's not good enough for WATCH, however. Although the packaging
"recommends the use of helmet, knee and elbow pads", the toy itself omits this
information. After all, the age group that this toy targets (6+) can read.
Do these toys belong on WATCH's list? Or does the organization take the fun out of being a kid? Weigh in by commenting on this story, and then come back tomorrow for the conclusion of this three-part series.
Steve Melito - The Y Files
Add to Technorati Favorites
   
|