Previous in Forum: Energy   Next in Forum: Moving on over.... Rockin on over.....
Close
Close
Close
Page 2 of 2: « First < Prev 1 2 Last »
Rating: Comments: Nested
Guru

Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 4484
Good Answers: 247

Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

06/12/2008 4:38 PM

Many of us get a kick out of quasi-scientific and anti-scientific "proofs" in which the experimenter is "hoisted by his own petard." One of our members brought to my attention a "proof" of this sort regarding using oxyhydrogen ("HHO", Brown's) gas to "improve" the performance of a motor scooter. As most people who are familiar with combustion science and chemistry can attest, there is no reason to think that generating oxyhydrogen on board a motor scooter and then feeding the gas to the engine would improve performance. The expectation would be that performance would be reduced, because more energy is required to split the water into H2 and O2 than can be recovered by burning the mixture.* In fact, because the typical internal combustion engine is 25% efficient, and a typical alternator is 65-70% efficient, simply breaking even would require that the electrolysis process be 500% efficient: clearly impossible to anyone outside the over-unity fringe group.

Promoters of these "fuel from water" scams come up with all sorts of fanciful reasons for why such schemes should work. It's hard to know how many of the people who profess such beliefs are truly scammers, and how many are simply gullible and uneducated in the chemistry and physics involved. Quite a large number are true scammers, and some of the more famous (like Dennis Lee and Stan Meyer) have been successfully prosecuted for fraud. In my experience looking over perhaps 20 websites promoting various electrolysers, every single promoter is an active, knowing scammer. For example, on one site, an old 6 cylinder pickup truck is shown running at idle, both with the electrolyser switched on and switched off. The "fuel consumption" at idle in both cases is several times higher than it would be in an ordinary engine running at idle: the engine supposedly sucks down 8 ounces of fuel extremely quickly. The "baseline" performance is so far from reality that nothing can be believed. It is as if the promoter is saying "This Honda Civic was getting 4 miles per gallon before HHO, and now gets 25 mpg with HHO!!" Plausible?

The amount of oxyhydrogen produced is infinitesimal, in all cases: 10 amps alternator draw is typical in these scams, so even at 100% electrolysis efficiency we'd be getting 120 watts worth of oxyhydrogen. In an engine of 100,000 to 200,000 watts output, you would not expect to measure any difference at all: you'd expect a net loss, but even on a dynamometer, a loss of .1% cannot be measured reliably. Scammers, however, claim magic at this point: that there is something about HHO** that "improves combustion". They even claim that large portions (15%, 20%, 30%) of the fuel going into an engine is not burned in the cylinder – which is completely untrue. Other scammers claims over-unity gas production by electrically "fracturing" water, rather that splitting it by "brute force" (However, splitting water at over unity has never, ever been demonstrated… and try as we may, there has never been any indication that it is possible to get more energy out of a system than we put in.) Engines are not inefficient because part of the fuel burns does not burn; they are inefficient because most of the heat is wasted. Injecting an infinitesimally small amount of H2, oxyhydrogen or dynamite will not change that.

The scammers say: "Prove it". Odd, because ordinarily it's the extraordinary claim that requires extraordinary proof. But it turns out that we now have one of the scammers inadvertently offering proof that his device does not work. The test is on a motor scooter, which is perfect because if there could be any effect, it would show up here, on an engine 1/100 the size of many American V8s. A motor scooter can easily generate 3 amps at 12 volts, to supply 36 watts worth of oxyhydrogen. The particular scooter in the test is tiny and slow, with about 4 HP, or 3000 watts. Thus the oxyhydrogen produced could have an energy value of about 1/100 the engine output. So we'd still not expect to be able to measure the change on any but the most sensitive dynamometers -- but if there were any change, we'd be about 10 times more likely to see it here than in any car or truck.

The scooter is also a great test vehicle, because the throttle can safely be held open all the time, meaning the engine is always at very near full output. (The test scooter will do about 60 kM/h – 37 mph.) Even the CVT drive train helps, because as load increases, the ratio automatically changes to help the engine run near its HP peak. Hills and headwinds are filtered out because the scooter slows but the engine continues run at its full output. We would want to measure fuel consumption in lb/hp/hr, just as engineers do, rather than distance per volume (mpg) because if one test run was against a head wind and the other with a tail wind, the distances and speeds would be different, but the time at full out put would be the same.

So… if you wanted a simple, reasonably valid test, running a scooter at full throttle for as long as it takes to consume a particular amount of fuel would be a good method. (You obviously cannot do this safely with a car – unless you are on a chassis dyno.) This is just what our scammer/tester does. He apparently lies about the distance (he claims the odometer is broken) because if you watch the speedometer, you can see that the top speed varies, in both runs, in similar ways. However, it is possible that one run was into a head wind, and the other with a tailwind (and the experimenter is just gullible, thinking the difference was a valid measure). But the important thing to measure is time, which is little influenced by headwind/tailwind, uphill/downhill provided the operator runs at full throttle, as he promises to do.

An oxyhydrogen generator on a car cannot be expected to have any measurable performance reduction (the energy consumption and oxyhydrogen production are far too small). Even on a scooter, the amount of energy consumed is too small to be able to reliable measure a performance reduction. But at least our scammer's test shows convincingly that there is no measurable difference with and without "HHO" injection. The running times are essentially identical, within just a couple seconds out of about 300.

The "without HHO" scooter test:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_fg5MYRht4U&amp;feature=user

The "with HHO" scooter test:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3TwFMOIyYnw&amp;feature=related

A post from a related thread where this scooter test came up:

http://cr4.globalspec.com/comment/236473/Re-Saving-MPG-with-Brown-Gas-Generator

* There is nothing special about water and hydrogen in this respect. Any reversible reaction gives off energy in one direction and consumes it in the other. Imagine if that were not the case. Our energy woes would have been eliminated years ago, if we could get heat out of a reaction in one direction and then get heat our again when it runs in the other direction. (Rust iron to make heat. Unrust iron to make more heat.)

** HHO is often said (by the fringe) to be "atomic" hydrogen and oxygen, rather than the mixture of H2 and O2 that it really is. There is no evidence that an electrolyser gives off anything but the common, expected mixture (assuming you don't do the usual, safer, gathering of the gases seperately) . How would one H stay separate from another H?

__________________
There is more to life than just eating mice.
Register to Reply
Interested in this topic? By joining CR4 you can "subscribe" to
this discussion and receive notification when new comments are added.

Good Answers:

These comments received enough positive votes to make them "good answers".

"Almost" Good Answers:

Check out these comments that don't yet have enough votes to be "official" good answers and, if you agree with them, vote them!
Active Contributor

Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Tacoma, Washington
Posts: 10
#98
In reply to #97
Find in discussion

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

03/22/2009 11:21 PM

6" X 6" X .020"

150mh

.040" gap

Register to Reply
Guru
Safety - Hazmat - New Member Safety - ESD - New Member Engineering Fields - Transportation Engineering - New Member Popular Science - Evolution - New Member Technical Fields - Procurement - New Member Hobbies - Target Shooting - New Member Popular Science - Cosmology - New Member Engineering Fields - Architectural Engineering - New Member Technical Fields - Marketing/Advertising - New Member Engineering Fields - Food Process Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Mariposa Ca
Posts: 5800
Good Answers: 114
#110
In reply to #96
Find in discussion

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

04/20/2009 12:12 AM

I meant a question based on reality, you gotta have a frequency to have resonance.

You gotta a real question?

I gave you a chance to come clean & correct yourself.

Should I direct you to some basic electronic educational materials?

Register to Reply
Active Contributor

Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Tacoma, Washington
Posts: 10
#111
In reply to #110

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

04/20/2009 1:07 AM

You did not ask me to supply a frequency... Could you not take it upon yourself to actually extrapolate a selected frequency(ies) and come up with the information requested or does your mother still spoon feed you?

Register to Reply
Guru
Safety - Hazmat - New Member Safety - ESD - New Member Engineering Fields - Transportation Engineering - New Member Popular Science - Evolution - New Member Technical Fields - Procurement - New Member Hobbies - Target Shooting - New Member Popular Science - Cosmology - New Member Engineering Fields - Architectural Engineering - New Member Technical Fields - Marketing/Advertising - New Member Engineering Fields - Food Process Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Mariposa Ca
Posts: 5800
Good Answers: 114
#112
In reply to #111

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

04/20/2009 12:44 PM

DC huh?

you think you already have an answer & are trying to test me!

do you have a point ?

If you have data present it.

Register to Reply
Guru
Hobbies - RC Aircraft - New Member Hobbies - Automotive Performance - New Member Hobbies - DIY Welding - New Member

Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Fort Lauderdale Florida
Posts: 5708
Good Answers: 123
#99
In reply to #92
Find in discussion

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

03/23/2009 11:18 AM

2. The U.S. Government is not going to up front money for the purpose of developing a technology that will essentially cost them tax revenue and any money that is available comes from, guess who... The oil industry.

Nor would they give millions of dollars for bonuses to executives that ran an industry into bankruptcy.

__________________
Bob
Register to Reply
Active Contributor

Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Tacoma, Washington
Posts: 10
#100
In reply to #99

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

03/23/2009 3:43 PM

Apples.... Oranges

Beautifully stated.

Register to Reply
Member

Join Date: Sep 2019
Posts: 5
#138
In reply to #72
Find in discussion

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

09/27/2019 4:09 PM

OK. It is clear that despite your long experience, you seem to miss the fundamentals of Energized Water Gas. Granted, there is confusion as to what to call it... HHO, Hydrogen, etc. But, the recent studies have confirmed that the gas does nuclear fission. So, it clearly is not the same stuff you refer to.

Let's look at the chemistry. EWG is a macro-molecule of water molecules. One explanation of this is in Dennis Klein's patent. The molecules are super rich in magnetism or electrical current, which they release in a very high energy burst that cascades or burns or sets off neighboring molecules to do the same thing. Thermally, the burn in free air is 58 deg. C. It will not boil water. However, the energy release has other properties. And the state change from gas to liquid is a powerful source of kinetic energy.

The molecules, like noble gas elements are diamagnetic. This causes molecules that are much larger than any element in the periodic table to be a gas at temperatures above minus 158 deg. C. It also makes it relatively unstable, at compression of just 5 atmospheres it will condense into liquid water (Another massive collective molecule which is why water makes such a great heat transfer medium and stays liquid when other molecules of the same mass as H2O are gasses.) The condensation reaction can also be initiated with a spark or flame. There is no one mix of water's collective molecules. Liquid water has 13 distinct triple points. EWG has been measured to be both denser and less dense than air. It also is capable of encapsulating foreign materials (in atomic form) within the structure of the EWG molecules.

The gas can be condensed in a fuel cell (no flame). It will produce 4 to 6 times the electricity produced by H2 and O2. The flame releases electricity. With an electrical motor, this makes it roughly 87 times more efficient pound for pound than gasoline in an ICE. It produces pure water upon condensation, regardless of what might be mixed with it. The phase change is the same as condensing steam and in an atmosphere can be as effective as steam powering pistons with an implosion. An auto equipped with a proper EWG system, similar to Denny Kleins' does not require spark plugs, runs cold compared to a gasoline engine and runs on implosion, not explosive power. Operating costs become non-existent.

The electrical discharge from the condensation is capable of doing both cold fission and fusion, although the fusion has been an accidental side effect reported by just a few experimenters. The fission has been repeatedly validated by physicists, and is the subject of intense study by certain start-ups.

The history of these effects have been intentionally confused with fanciful explanations by scientists to protect the economy. The most popular one is sonoluminescence from cavitation. Long understood to dissolve any propeller and impeller, the explanation of the observed electrical discharge is that the sound produced by a condensing bubble creates light and fractures the hardest metals.

Research has confirmed the fission of materials and transmutation of substances in contact with the gas as it condenses... of course the theory remains affirmed, as high speed cameras have recorded the singular point of collapse within the bubble, which mathematically must generate an extreme amount of pressure. Proving, most people will see what they expect, and not challenge their beliefs. And also affirming the effectiveness of separating the sciences into disciplines which suppress innovation.

Essentially any method that puts energy into water will create the gas, but one must be able to minimize the normal effect of generating steam or hydrogen gas to maximize the yields of EWG. IR tuned lasers, cavitation/motion, electricity, magnetism. And the water does not have to be liquid, it can be a vapor (lightning is most likely a discharge of EWG). Even motion next to surfaces with different electrical potential or conductivity will assist the formation of EWG. Klein proved he created the gas with less energy than is required to make hydrogen.

When you cavitate water with other matter present, the nuclear fission adds to the energy absorbed by the water and one can heat water to steam with 30% less energy than directly heating it. A successful company was launched on this principle, but had to limit the applications to chemical slurries, as the water heaters self-destructed over time (Based on sonoluminescence there is no fix for this; however, a magnetized cavitator should fix the problem of self-destruction.) Problems with steam and water pipes self-destructing and propellers and impellers could easily be remedied.

There are dozens of patents on water purification systems that work by cavitation alone. I suspect the sacrifice of the cavitators has compromised the market potential for such systems. There are applications where the gas generators are used to purify toxic wastes, ironically some of them are used in cleaning up the pollution created in drilling for oil. One does not need AC power to make the gas, DC systems with low voltages and cavitation and the addition of certain conductivity enhancing additives seem to be very effective.

The discharge is actually an Ether release, but most would recognize it as electrical. The Joe-Cell uses principles of conducting Ether that Tesla demonstrated, and runs cars on the Ether without discharging the water from the reaction. A minor footnote in the history you've recorded here. But, worth noting.

The burn temperature is not enough to start a fire, but it does cold fission. Yule Brown demonstrated that he could neutralize hard radioactive materials. The mechanism should be clear. It should also be obvious why the torch only produces water and how it could melt dissimilar materials for soldering or welding, how it could burn through carbon or fire-brick or titanium, while keeping the torch at temperatures that could be handled directly without gloves.

Now, it is typical to confuse the facts with social, political, and economic references as to the truth of all this and the attempts of so many to make money off the technology. Who wouldn't want a system that could neutralize the millions of pounds of nuclear waste? Or eliminate the climate crises? Or solve the energy needs of a planet? That answer is simple, the elimination of trillions of dollars from the economy in the energy and motive industries would destroy governments. And the wealth of the leaders of our world would be seriously compromised if not totally devalued.

They have continued to discredit and suppress everyone who has come close to bringing this technology to the public. And there is no indication they will stop. Be safe. Do not go public with this technology. It is forbidden. But it is real.

Peace, B

Register to Reply Score 2 for Off Topic
Guru
Technical Fields - Technical Writing - New Member Engineering Fields - Piping Design Engineering - New Member

Join Date: May 2009
Location: Richland, WA, USA
Posts: 21017
Good Answers: 795
#139
In reply to #138

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

09/27/2019 6:42 PM

Absolute nonsense.

__________________
In vino veritas; in cervisia carmen; in aqua E. coli.
Register to Reply Score 1 for Off Topic
Participant

Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 3
#129
In reply to #71
Find in discussion

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

10/22/2009 3:24 PM

Unable to follow your site hhogassavermpg.com. It was removed. Any advise?

Register to Reply
Guru
Safety - Hazmat - New Member Safety - ESD - New Member Engineering Fields - Transportation Engineering - New Member Popular Science - Evolution - New Member Technical Fields - Procurement - New Member Hobbies - Target Shooting - New Member Popular Science - Cosmology - New Member Engineering Fields - Architectural Engineering - New Member Technical Fields - Marketing/Advertising - New Member Engineering Fields - Food Process Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Mariposa Ca
Posts: 5800
Good Answers: 114
#130
In reply to #129

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

10/22/2009 11:32 PM

That would seem to be an indication of the level of success of the project.

There would 2 different ways to get federal approval, as a fuel additive of as an emission reduction device...

Register to Reply
Guru
Hobbies - RC Aircraft - New Member Hobbies - Automotive Performance - New Member Hobbies - DIY Welding - New Member

Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Fort Lauderdale Florida
Posts: 5708
Good Answers: 123
#69
In reply to #67
Find in discussion

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

03/16/2009 11:46 PM

The hydrogen you are adding to your engine is a fuel. If your engine produces that much additional mileage with the added fuel, it was not running at the proper fuel mixture before. Your hydrogen generator is producing at a constant rate. Your car is operating at varying loads and speeds. At what load and speed does the mixture become so good?

If you were using a simple lawn mower engine, It would be easier to believe. Any car that was sold in the last 20 years that was that far away from correct mixture ratio would never have passed emission inspections.

I am no where as comfortable with the technicalities of hydrogen production as Blink, but I do not see how adding additional fuel to a properly running engine can produce the results you have claimed.

__________________
Bob
Register to Reply
Active Contributor

Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Tacoma, Washington
Posts: 10
#103
In reply to #69

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

03/25/2009 5:28 PM

"The hydrogen you are adding to your engine is a fuel."

Hydrogen is not a fuel, hydrogen gas as part of a catalyst, changes the performance of a combustive reaction.

hydrogen gas on its own does nothing without an oxidizer, ie: oxygen. It is the addition of oxygen intermixed with the hydrogen gas that determines the reactive force output from the oxidation of said gas.

Hydrogen as an additive to the intake of hydrocarbon fuel and "atmospheric air" into an internal combustion engine creates an intermix of gases that increase the efficiency of that catalyst in the combustion chamber.

This information is in the very documents that has been claimed as hearsay.

CCE, California Environmental Engineering - TESTED

AHATL, American Hydrogen Assocation Test Lab - TESTED

Corrections Canada - TESTED

"The results of these tests were able to confirm the claims made about this technology:

the emissions will be reduced, the horsepower will increase and the fuel consumption will be reduced."

Register to Reply
Associate
Engineering Fields - Automotive Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Somewhere in the Pacifics...
Posts: 43
#70

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

03/16/2009 11:46 PM

Hi Ken, Hi everyone!..

I dont think there is really a debate here... first of all, I don't claim any over-unity in my experiments or demos.. secondly, I respect the laws governing this science. I believe that the energy used in extracting hydrogen is always bigger than the energy derived from the hydroxy gas extracted. I believe that every equation is an equilibrium in itself... that everything is a balance... otherwise, we will have some sort of thermonuclear fission or fusion.

In light of the above, a running scooter or car is an equation in itself by itself... adding on board Hydroxy on demand will change the whole equation... but will not make it out of balance since the system becomes part of the whole equation... which is... the new equation.

Hydroxy on demand (On board electrolysis) will take a portion of the energy output of the whole equation... it will also add energy back into the equation. But this energy will always be at a loss... just like batteries connected or grounded to a cars body... will always have some voltage drop at some areas of higher resistance. There can never be over unity unless you remove the hampering factors like gravity, friction, barometric pressures, resistance - both electrical and hydraulic pressures. Theoretically - this applies. To verify if the theory is correct, we go to the mills... cause dynanometer tests are much closer to the truth with very small margins for errors.

In my experience... dyno testing included... Dyno testers step on the gas pedal full throttle on third as common practice... this is of course necessary in order to get a good reading.

In the real world... we only need to apply very little pedal pressure to maintain cruising speed. This -will never show up in a dyno since applying more pedal pressure will definitely negate any significant torque or brake horsepower gains since the little hydroxy enhancement will not show up in these power bands... if the system is efficiently designed or installed and calibrated... it may show up but in little amounts.

Real gains can only be achieved when the electrolyzer produces enough gas to supplmenent or anhance stoichiometric afr combustion when it's causing tolerable - insignificant load figures on the engine. This is better achieved if the energy used to electrolyze is not coming from the alternator but from another -non mechanical load device such as a Thermoelectric Peltier plates coupled to the exhaust pipes. (This is ideal)... but in the les complex installations - less load on the alternator is the only way to go in order to benefit from electrolytic fuel reformers.

The scooter gained 25% only because the old battery is not receiving any DC charge anymore but it is merely serving as a buffer zone - by simply passes the energy straight to my electrolyzer... since I only placed a hose directly in the throttle body - I cannot get enough vacuum pressure so my Hydroxy cell needed to produce more to the point that it becomes a sort of forced induction system... again, this is not ideal. Ideal is - vacuum assisted fuel feed induction. The vacuum needs to be stronger than the hydroxy gas output.

With a 4 stroke scooter, the vacuum is much more stronger, and more noticeable gains can be attained.

We conducted baseline runs for three days... a/b,a/b,a/b approach. Our baseline showed 6 to 8 km. per liter, the route is constant. the enhanced runs with the unit on... showed initially 50% gains.... the scooter owner was excited already with this figure... until I switched the unit to normal power mode - with 3 electrodes working... that it went to as much as 300% plus gains... about 24km per liter. The test driver - an uninterested party noticed the performance difference and that absence of hard fumes from the exhaust. He was clueless of what we were doing, he is merely following the orders to test and drive it on a specific route and fill it up every time afterwards to the same pump. The test continued for about a week.

This is a China made scooter, it has a relatively higher power to weight ratio... the only thing I added in the equation is this small electrolyzer system... and a metal treatment oil which I use for racing... similar to Daniel Dingels oil. This serves as the engines protection against water moisture... in case water gets in in its liquid form.

a/b tests where also done in the emissions testing center... It got 75% lesser CO the moment the switch was turned on. .. HC is also low (new vehicle standards). No tweakings made on the carburetor... we simply added it in.

The tire pressures are filled to 30PSI, it wasnt changed. The scooter also has a CVT... so more or less, all the variables are set or assumed to be constants.

One thing significant here... the emission or exhaust gas is not irritating to the nose, even if you spend a minute behind this bike during idling.

Regards...

__________________
We are no better than the causes we are fighting for...
Register to Reply
Anonymous Poster
#81

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

03/19/2009 8:34 AM

Here's a link an exhaust test of an HHO'd vehicle that just passed testing, which is now posted on Youtube. I've pasted the text from the video, too:

Check this video out HHO Charade Actual Emission Footage 1 of 2 Way below EURO-2 benchmarks... This 18 year old car emits only 0.11% CO and only 250ppm of HC.
EURO 2 is .5%CO and 250ppm HC. Cars of this age are permissible with .6% CO and 800 ppm of HC.

Tested yesterday.... I am entertained with the reactions on the faces of the emissions inspectors...

Once again - tested and proven.

Part 2 is where I will show the Certificate from the Test.

R. Matthies

.

Register to Reply
Guru

Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 4484
Good Answers: 247
#83
In reply to #81

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

03/19/2009 1:39 PM

I am glad to see that you willing to show that HHO boosting can more than double emissions.

Coming over to the science and engineering side, however, does not get you off the hook for some of your other rather fantastic claims. There is nothing in this test, for instance, that supports your fantastic claims for 50x improvement in HHO production rate (which would suggest roughly 2500% efficiency, in comparison to the common 50% efficiency). Nor does it support your claim of "inventing" AC electrolysis, which, you must know, was also claimed by Yull Brown, no doubt the most famous HHO "fraud" or "inventor", depending upon perspective. So if you know that AC electrolysis was invented long ago but you claim to have invented it... what impression does that create in the minds of people trying to determine if anything you say has value?

But in any case, I gave my son my old 1990 Daihatsu Charade several months ago. To be registered, it must pass the state emissions test. Its HC ppm value was 108, less than half the value you quote. Thus, we could conclude that this particular HHO unit doubled emissions, and that it substantially reduced combustion efficiency, as compared to my worn-out car. The evidence you provide shows that the HHO equipped car sends more than twice the fuel unburned, out the tailpipe. HHO frauds, (and of course I am not immediately including you in that group) positively love to talk about the large amounts of fuel that otherwise go out the tailpipe. (We know such people are frauds, because large amounts of fuel do not go out the tailpipe or into the catalytic converter.) The reason they love to talk this way, is that they have realized they can no longer scam people on the basis of fuel replacement, (energy balance) which would suggest violation of thermodynamic laws. So they make up another reason that HHO should work: it enables more complete burning of the fuel. You've clearly shown that this other reason is not sound either.

Many of today's HHO units are near perfect replicas of the 1918 patented unit. It didn't work. What has changed over the years is the number of "reasons" for these devices working presented by frauds and the ill-informed, but tests at NASA and elsewhere show that these "reasons" are incorrect.

Interesting that this HHO equipped car cannot even come close to performing as well as my old clunker, which is clearly on it's last legs, burning several quarts of oil between changes, and which I bought for $700 twelve years ago, never dreaming that it would still be running now. It could properly be called a "junker" but is twice as clean burning as your example. If my car were in good condition, we'd expect emissions to be even lower.

The EPA is set up to test fuel mileage improvement devices. Any auto company which refuses such tests cannot advertise their mileage figures here. Thus, imagine how easy it would be to gain credibility with a legitimate test rather than with silly videos, that, for all we know, were produced by people with little regard for the truth. Yet no HHO device has been shown by the EPA to have any beneficial effect. Go figure: such a great opportunity to gain credibility in an industry swimming in fraud, but no promoter takes advantage of it.

I am glad to see that you have flipped-flopped into valuing dyno tests as a legitimate method for measuring HHO performance. I take this as a sign that you may be gaining appreciation for science. I am also glad to see that you have produced evidence that shows that HHO devices reduce combustion efficiency and increase emissions. I would not extrapolate from this test to all of these devices -- the scientific expectation is that they should have no effect, and the valid tests (by NASA, Popular Mechanics, etc.) support that view. So I think we can chalk this up to test error -- doubling emissions seems unlikely, although a test with diesel (not some YouTube fakery but a real test) did show that smoke increased with HHO injection. My own experiments from decades ago also showed the same thing: that HHO injection has no measurable effect in spark ignition engines at the incredibly small injection levels produced by HHO booster units.

It is puzzling that you so quickly changed your mind though, re dyno tests. No need to respond, wasting more CR4 bandwidth, I am not interested in your epiphany -- but I am glad you have decided to at least show that HHO has an adverse effect on emissions. It seems like a small step in the right direction.

I don't know that a "part 2" will be necessary, unless you really want to "rub their noses in it" in regard to those HHO scammers. I doubt that they really care about your "proof" that the devices increase emissions. But suit yourself -- in my experience they just keep coming back with distractions and implausible excuses.

__________________
There is more to life than just eating mice.
Register to Reply
Associate
Engineering Fields - Automotive Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Somewhere in the Pacifics...
Posts: 43
#86
In reply to #83

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

03/20/2009 7:42 PM

Just to clarify some information:

1. First of all, that Charade tested hasn't changed oil for 2 years.

2. The Spark Plugs are 5 years old

3. The Carb hasnt been tuned to optimal setting by a qualified mechanic or technician.

4. The Carb is making rich AFR mixture.

5. The timing isn't even set to the correct degree.

With the above conditions; we should have seen a lot higher figure than what we got.

This car has the Hydroxy on board since last year, the device wasnt switched on for about a week since we are monitoring it's consumption with out enhancement.

But since it was due for registration - we had to turn it on for a few hours before reaching the center.

Obviously, there are Hydrocarbon deposits in the exhaust system that are still being purged and apparently being picked up by the probe.

Another point:

With the device on, it takes more pedal pressure to bring the car up to 100kph.

With the device on, even with a light pedal pressure or position - cruising speeds of 120kph is easier to attain and sustain.

Street racing this car is almost done everytime its out in the highways... with the device on, the car seems to run with Nitrous. In fact, leaving the pack is a breeze with just a flick of the switch.

In normal mode - There is more pedal pressure and higher rpm's needed...

Dont take my word on it... Ask the guy driving a MAZDA protege trying to race me the other night. In normal mode, he was able to reach me before the toll gate after I passed him 2 km earlier. After the toll gate, he had a head start, I just chased him, with the device switched on this time. After 1 km. I was already running pass 140km per hour. And the whole traffic was like - on a stop... I passed him from the rear to his right side - I think he was a bit shocked seeing a fast daihatsu - stiching the whole length of this coastal road. I continued driving with Hyper speed mode for the rest of the stretch... One thing is for sure... I did it with out over-revving the car. The pedal position was only 1/2 to 1/4. The proof is always in the pudding. I have been driving Hydrogen on demand cars for the past 2 years and I can never drive another car without it anymore. The absence of the hard toxic smell is addicting.

There were others zero fighters gunned down by this spitfire... (so to speak). An F150, a Ricer Boys lowered Nissan Sentra with Simota intake, A Honda Civic... and many more. Maybe - THe Charade is bone stock... perhaps the driver is modified?... :-) not at all.

For many years in Racing - there was a point that I was addicted to the smell of castrol oil burning with the fuel... this gave me a good feeling - racing season. But since I started seeing and feeling the difference with a hydrogen enhanced system... the absence of the bad fuel smell is unlike anything else.

Now the next question is probably Fuel Mileage?...

__________________
We are no better than the causes we are fighting for...
Register to Reply
Guru
Hobbies - RC Aircraft - New Member Hobbies - Automotive Performance - New Member Hobbies - DIY Welding - New Member

Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Fort Lauderdale Florida
Posts: 5708
Good Answers: 123
#87
In reply to #86

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

03/21/2009 5:41 PM

You are not the only one that has discovered the benefits of HHO. John Force has sold his older design drag cars. By April 1 he will unveil his new fleet of stock Ford Focus sedans equipped with High efficiency HHO systems.

__________________
Bob
Register to Reply
Associate
Engineering Fields - Automotive Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Somewhere in the Pacifics...
Posts: 43
#88
In reply to #87

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

03/22/2009 8:10 AM

Is this addressed to me?

I thought I was facing a battlefront against a debunking issue here... suddenly I am now in a race?

I guess this is my que.

Well, it's been a pleasure exchanging talks here.

tell then.

Cheers everyone.

__________________
We are no better than the causes we are fighting for...
Register to Reply
Guru
Safety - Hazmat - New Member Safety - ESD - New Member Engineering Fields - Transportation Engineering - New Member Popular Science - Evolution - New Member Technical Fields - Procurement - New Member Hobbies - Target Shooting - New Member Popular Science - Cosmology - New Member Engineering Fields - Architectural Engineering - New Member Technical Fields - Marketing/Advertising - New Member Engineering Fields - Food Process Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Mariposa Ca
Posts: 5800
Good Answers: 114
#89
In reply to #88

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

03/22/2009 12:54 PM

Still waiting for the question?

Register to Reply
Active Contributor

Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Tacoma, Washington
Posts: 10
#85
In reply to #81

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

03/20/2009 4:06 PM

1 - You really should register so you can acknowledge any feedback

2 - It would be great if you made your video's on YouTube "Public" so we could view them.

On another forum there is a posting of an individuals Emissions report on a Deisel Engine. 0% CO, 0% HC.

I do love when engineers jump in with their declaration of science and technology.

Sure wish they would actually prove it to themselves by actually running the tests before they spout their prowess

Register to Reply
Guru
Safety - Hazmat - New Member Safety - ESD - New Member Engineering Fields - Transportation Engineering - New Member Popular Science - Evolution - New Member Technical Fields - Procurement - New Member Hobbies - Target Shooting - New Member Popular Science - Cosmology - New Member Engineering Fields - Architectural Engineering - New Member Technical Fields - Marketing/Advertising - New Member Engineering Fields - Food Process Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Mariposa Ca
Posts: 5800
Good Answers: 114
#106

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

03/31/2009 10:46 AM

Gee,

I'm convinced when can I buy 1?

I'd like the extra smoke & mirrors please!

Register to Reply
Anonymous Poster
#113

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

04/21/2009 4:22 PM

Idiot, hho has been around since the 1970's NASA even tested this HHO and said it worked... Get your facts right,,, I've got on on my car and have had it on there for months.. works great.. I am a sales rep and travel 80,000 a year.. I'll gladly laugh at your article when I'm in the islands on the $12K I'll save this year on gas.. So keep believing it doesn't work... I guess I have the only one on earth that does, lucky me.

Register to Reply Score 1 for Off Topic
Guru
Hobbies - HAM Radio - New Member Engineering Fields - Mechanical Engineering - New Member United States - Member - New Member

Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Kiefer OK
Posts: 1325
Good Answers: 22
#114
In reply to #113

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

04/21/2009 9:02 PM

Why should we believe you, Edgar? You give us no identifying information about yourself. You don't specify whether you travel 80,000 miles or kilometers. You don't say whether you are spending US or Canadian dollars. You don't say if the islands are in the Caribbean or the South Pacific. You also do not say how you know you will save $12K.

The originator of this thread has mentioned the NASA report, and has said that HHO scammers claim it supports their claims when it does not, and the scammers must not have actually read it. I deduce from this and your comment that you have not read the entire thread.

You present more unknown than knowns. The only things we do know for sure about you are that you are a traveling sales rep (which does not speak highly of your scientific, engineering, or mathematical knowledge), and you have the gall to call a man with experience in automotive engineering and HHO experiments an idiot.

Another thing, you say you have had the device on your car for months. I don't even need a calculator to tell me you must be saving over $1000 a month on gas. Unless you're driving a Snap-On tool truck, I doubt you are spending even that much on fuel.

__________________
I wonder..... Would Schrödinger's cat play with a ball of string theory?
Register to Reply
Participant

Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 3
#115

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

08/19/2009 4:44 AM

I have been interested in this topic for some time and as you all know getting any real information is very difficult. I am a mechanical engineer thus I require proof to make conclusions. Initially the concept appears completely impossible, it describes a perpetual motion machine. The problem with this topic is the people who are capable of producing reliable test results, (engineers, physists, etc.) will not spend the time or effort required. While the theory that is used in the scams is completely bogus, an internal combustion engine (ICE) is a complicated system, and it is possible that their are other factors at play which may be resulting in the effect that is observed. Analysing parts of this in abstact (ie testing HHO output, and testing for calorific value), will not tell the full story, and may give false conclusions.

I would like to point out the following points regarding the proof of why this "technology" is false. Some of the infomation given here i cannot validate and if anyone has any proof either way I would like to see it(as would we all).

Brown's gas is NOT a stoichiometric mixture of H2 and O2. During electrolosis the H2O molecule is split into H and HO. If this remains between the electrodes for sufficient time the HO will split, and the atoms will all combine into their diatomic states(O2 and H2). However if the gas is not given sufficient time it will leave the generator as a mixture of H* and HO*, the so-called "Brown's Gas". These molecules are free radicals, which not stable and hence if given the time they will form more stable states. However if these are exposed to a flame the will combine very readily with other molecules. This is the reason that a browns gas flame will change temperature depending on the material in the flame.

In reality the output of a HHO generator is a mixture of H, H2, HO and O2, as well as a small amount of water vapour. The ratios of these will vary and this is why it is so difficult to perform repeatable test results.

Testing of H2 injection will not give the same results as HHO injection. Because of the free radical hydrogen the effect will by vary different and the results from testing with H2 cannot apply. Testing needs to be performed with HHO that is produced from a brown's gas generator.

It puzzles me that so many people could be claiming results and it all be in their imagination. There are many scams, with fiction explanations of the "science" behind their device. However their are also many individuals, with no financial interest in the subject, who attest major fuel savings.

While the exact amounts claimed are very unlikely, there is some credit to be given. Without a controlled test it will be impossible to get exact, and accurate figures. However with a 20% saving it would be quite obvious when you fill up, so i do not beleive that people would continue attest such great improvements if there were actually no improvment at all.

PLEASE TEAR THIS APART AS I BELEIVE WHAT I SAY BUT CANNOT PROVE IT. I ALSO CANNOT DIS-PROVE IT, SO PLEASE TRY SO THIS CAN BECOME A DISCUSSION AND WE MAY BE ABLE TO SHED SOME LIGHT ON THIS DARK SUBJECT.

Register to Reply
Guru
Safety - Hazmat - New Member Safety - ESD - New Member Engineering Fields - Transportation Engineering - New Member Popular Science - Evolution - New Member Technical Fields - Procurement - New Member Hobbies - Target Shooting - New Member Popular Science - Cosmology - New Member Engineering Fields - Architectural Engineering - New Member Technical Fields - Marketing/Advertising - New Member Engineering Fields - Food Process Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Mariposa Ca
Posts: 5800
Good Answers: 114
#116
In reply to #115

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

08/19/2009 2:53 PM

Did you read this thread?

We've gone over all the reasons HHO generation is not a net gain...

Here's another explanation The 13 HHO lies

Register to Reply
Anonymous Poster
#117

HYDROXY DEBATE IS OVER - MAGAZINE PUBLISHES HHO DYNO PRINTOUTS

09/21/2009 8:03 PM

Backseat testers and opinion makers can now relax.

A UK magazine has published complete printouts of the result of "with" and "without" a Hydroxy fuel cell.

This is the most prestigious scooter magazine in the world, and the journalist is very experienced.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JCytZYKL3i8

Register to Reply Score 1 for Off Topic
Guru
Safety - Hazmat - New Member Safety - ESD - New Member Engineering Fields - Transportation Engineering - New Member Popular Science - Evolution - New Member Technical Fields - Procurement - New Member Hobbies - Target Shooting - New Member Popular Science - Cosmology - New Member Engineering Fields - Architectural Engineering - New Member Technical Fields - Marketing/Advertising - New Member Engineering Fields - Food Process Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Mariposa Ca
Posts: 5800
Good Answers: 114
#118
In reply to #117

Re: HYDROXY DEBATE IS OVER - MAGAZINE PUBLISHES HHO DYNO PRINTOUTS

09/21/2009 9:52 PM

Please do post this "proof"

Please do go to the other thread & read the discussion of dyno results & the level of accuracy to be expected

These scooter guys have been around & have yet to prove much of anything.

Repeating an untruth does not make it true.

At least don't hide behind a guest tag

Register to Reply
Associate
Engineering Fields - Automotive Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Somewhere in the Pacifics...
Posts: 43
#119
In reply to #118

Re: HYDROXY DEBATE IS OVER - MAGAZINE PUBLISHES HHO DYNO PRINTOUTS

09/22/2009 4:13 AM

No offense meant... but AFAIK IMHO... The only untruth being repeated here is that HHO doesnt work. Firstly, not all HHO cells or systems are the same. (Thats a fact) We cannot generalize all HHO to be one and the same. Just last week, our skeptical mechanic has been doing baseline runs without HHO and after with HHO... 14km each run - doing 5 runs for each mode respectively. The run was done for 2 days. The run was made after we have fixed the battery draining issues and rectified or stabilized the amperage draw of the cell. The KPL without HHO was 26. The highest KPL with HHO is 31. Average KPL without = 23.87KPL Average KPL with HHO = 28.11KPL The driver is ecstatic... because of the fact that for every full tank (5 Liter)... he gets an extra 15 to 25km free! It's not really free... the extra 15 to 25 km actually comes from the HHO. This is only 10ml. per minute of HHO induced. 0.1 lpm of HHO is about 25Liters of HHO per 4 hours of use. or about 6.5 Li. or more per hour. So 6.5 Liters of HHO gas spread out during the whole duration of the bikes operation can and will definitely have some effect. And the proof - once again is too obvious. The Mechanic uses an old Honda TMX 155cc 4 stroke, he tested it with full skepticism. We let him test this on his own, we were at the point of being exasperated ourselves with the number of tests we have burden ourselves for the past months. After he sent us the results or data, the driver or bike owner was more excited than us. He is now a believer. His witnesses are the pump attendant and another boy who is in charge of the credit card. The world is indeed round. And that's the Whole Truth and nothing but the truth.

__________________
We are no better than the causes we are fighting for...
Register to Reply Score 1 for Off Topic
Guru
Safety - Hazmat - New Member Safety - ESD - New Member Engineering Fields - Transportation Engineering - New Member Popular Science - Evolution - New Member Technical Fields - Procurement - New Member Hobbies - Target Shooting - New Member Popular Science - Cosmology - New Member Engineering Fields - Architectural Engineering - New Member Technical Fields - Marketing/Advertising - New Member Engineering Fields - Food Process Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Mariposa Ca
Posts: 5800
Good Answers: 114
#120
In reply to #119

Re: HYDROXY DEBATE IS OVER - MAGAZINE PUBLISHES HHO DYNO PRINTOUTS

09/22/2009 11:24 AM

No that's anecdotal opinion.

A couple of runs is not proof or data.

Long term thousands of km's, blind testing....

We've been here before...

Repeating an misrepresentation does not make it true....

Register to Reply
Associate
Engineering Fields - Automotive Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Somewhere in the Pacifics...
Posts: 43
#122
In reply to #120

Re: HYDROXY DEBATE IS OVER - MAGAZINE PUBLISHES HHO DYNO PRINTOUTS

09/22/2009 1:02 PM

I will ignore the redundant insinuations... With regards to thousands of km. blind testing, I have been doing that on my own car for over a year already. I have been logging mileage data also. Just to give you an idea of what I discovered so far.... comparing it with recent Econo runs conducted by Honda and Shell... I can just laugh at their numbers. I will try not to be sarcastic - but they get their high mileage figures with hypermiling. I get the same without hypermiling.... more if I did!... but that would be cheating with my unfair advantage. Anyway - I find no more reason and enthusiasm proving anything here furthermore. Until then.

__________________
We are no better than the causes we are fighting for...
Register to Reply
Anonymous Poster
#121
In reply to #117

Re: HYDROXY DEBATE IS OVER - MAGAZINE PUBLISHES HHO DYNO PRINTOUTS

09/22/2009 11:47 AM

Many "experienced" journalists have had to backtrack on their support of HHO devices after finding that the tests were inadequate, rigged, or misinterpreted. In this case, the "tests" are not those of the magazine, but of the promoters. Much of the text in the article is also quotes from the promoters, (such as from Enrico, Rob Mathies), and there is nothing enlightening or of substance from the "journalist". Nowhere does the journalist say, for example, that "Our tests clearly show that HHO has a beneficial effect on fuel efficiency."

What is this debate to which you refer? As far as I know, the use of HHO has never been seriously debated, any more than miracle sparkplugs which double your mileage are seriously debated. Serious debate occurs (on other topics) in the combustion journals, and as far as I know, there has not been a single article in real journals about using HHO to improve fuel efficiency. HHO has been promoted for what, 100 years (?) as a magic bullet, but was dismissed decades ago as the stuff of charlatans. Please give references to scientific articles.

Thanks, KBJ.

Register to Reply
Participant

Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 3
#123

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

09/22/2009 7:51 PM

I find it amusing that Garth and others immediately knock any test that is in favor of HHO, but give total faith in those that appear to disprove the claims. Firstly I should clarify my position, I am neither a believer or non-believer, as neither side has been proved. The NASA test that has been extensively mentioned does not actually test the viability of hydrogen(and definitely not HHO) enhancement under normal conditions. The aim of the experiment was to investigate if hydrogen injection would allow the running of very lean fuel mixtures, which it did. However the effect of H2 injection was not tested for mixtures close to stoichiometric. The test by 'popular mechanic' magazine is not better than a 'mithbusters' test, whom have repeatedly failed to prove well known phenomenon, such as the destruction of a structure via excitation at the natural frequency.

On the same token I have not seen any real proof that HHO does work, only descriptions of the procedure and the final numbers. There is a large amount of info missing (ie the raw data). And there is no proof of the data analysis.

My challenge for Enriko is to give some raw data that we can analyse ourselves. This may give credibility to the results you present. The same goes for any other that claim to have proof: show it to the world in its entirety. If you are secretive then no one will ever beleive you!

Dynometer testing will be the ultimate test, however one must know exactly what they are looking for in order to create an appropriate testing regime. This will only come from the real world testing.

Register to Reply
Guru
Safety - Hazmat - New Member Safety - ESD - New Member Engineering Fields - Transportation Engineering - New Member Popular Science - Evolution - New Member Technical Fields - Procurement - New Member Hobbies - Target Shooting - New Member Popular Science - Cosmology - New Member Engineering Fields - Architectural Engineering - New Member Technical Fields - Marketing/Advertising - New Member Engineering Fields - Food Process Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Mariposa Ca
Posts: 5800
Good Answers: 114
#124
In reply to #123

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

09/22/2009 10:46 PM

You haven't gotten the whole context of the conversation, which is actually taking place across multiple threads.

I don't dismiss any "test", I'm still waiting to see one, You know actual science...

I'm with you let's see the data! If HHO works it's a no brainer for a car or truck maker, The bottom line rules, they aren't the sorts to leave money on the table. Heard some claims about reducing emissions too still waiting for evidence of that.

Try HHO test plan

Register to Reply
Anonymous Poster
#128
In reply to #123

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

09/24/2009 2:51 PM

I find it amusing that Garth and others immediately knock any test that is in favor of HHO, but give total faith in those that appear to disprove the claims.

You are both rude and easily amused, but the central fact is this: HHO has been associated with fraud for decades, and has never been demonstrated to work as claimed for fuel efficiency improvement (for any of the various reasons and excuses claimed) by any university study or government agency. On the contrary, government agencies have prosecuted the perpetrators for fraud. The claims of huge gains in fuel efficiency (from 20% on up to anything the promoter thinks he can get away with) would, if there were any merit to them, have all the manufacturer's scrambling to put these units on their cars -- virtually for free, because there is no intellectual property involved. So Garth's reaction appears to be normal, healthy skepticism.

Your assertion that H2 injection was not tested for mixtures close to stoichiometric is incorrect, if I recall -- but I haven't read that study in a long time. If it was not tested in that old NASA study, it has certainly been tested more recently -- and the results have been as you'd expect -- no beneficial effect, just as adding any flammable gas to a stoichiometric mixture displaces air and over-richens the mixture.

I doubt that Garth will "immediately knock" a test of HHO from a well-regarded university with a solid combustion program, if the test appears to use reasonable methodology. Produce the results of such a test and you can see what his response is. If Toyota starts putting HHO units on their Prius and demonstrates to the EPA that their mileage has improved because of such an addition, I doubt that Garth will "immediately knock" such EPA testing.

If you know otherwise, then provide links to legitimate studies published in appropriate journals -- then you would be making a real contribution here rather than making fun of the reasonable and reasoned responses of engineering and science people. If you'd like to make a case for disbelief in science, then start a thread to that effect, if you are so inclined.

But from what I've read in this discussion, it looks like you have, on the one hand, legitimate, educated engineers and scientists, and on the other hand people who are either incredibly naive (accepting, as you do, Yul Brown's BS re monatomic H -- for which there is no support in real science -- and which you have mis-characterized in your earlier post), seriously uneducated in the subject matter, or unethical.

If you want to appear "scientific" then, at least produce some evidence from university studies that the output of an HHO welder contains meaningful amounts of H. Legitimate vendors of such units (with whom I have worked) make no such claims, and verifying your claim would only require a legitimate measurement by a university chemisty department. There is interest in H for propulsion (rocket) purposes, but it is very difficult to retain for longer than milliseconds, and does not show up at the end of a welding hose in meaningful amounts. You claim otherwise: produce the data. Calculate the dwell time of the gases in the hose at the flow rates Enrico quotes. (BTW, we also never made any claim that our torches adjust their temperature to materials automatically, regardless of what we think it in the hose. Go ahead: hold your hand on front of an oxyhydrogen torch. You'll quickly learn a lesson.)

"Analyzing" "data" from an HHO promoter, when you have not witnessed the test methodology, is not reasonable science. Insulting the Popular Mechanics editor without providing detailed explanations of the flaws in his methodology is also unreasonable behavior. From as much as I have read re the test, he is correct that there should be a near immediate change in fuel flow when the unit is turned on if it is having any effect. But he observed no change at all, just as scientists and engineers would expect. I think he makes the point that as a combustion catalyst, rather than as a fuel replacer (which HHO frauds used to claim as the "reason" their units worked -- and many still do, evidently) the amounts produced are far too small to make any difference at all.

There is no need, contrary to your claim, to do loads of road tests (which are subject to far too much variability even if done by disinterested parties -- and useless if done by the promoters themselves) first. Do real dyno tests first -- this is the way engines and engine mods are developed. Produce the results. Then see if the results carry over into the real world. Those who claim that the reverse should be done, are bent on confusing the issues. Approach MIT -- they've got a world class lab for this stuff, and would be happy to be the university that overturns conventional science.

When you have real dyno data, come back -- I'd be interested to read about it. I'll check back here occasionally. If you have real chemistry data that shows that there is any meaningful amount of H in the usual H2+O2 welding gas mixture, present that -- I and my colleagues would be thrilled to hear about it. Otherwise, your indiscriment weaving together of science and pseudo-science comes across as intellectually dishonest, no matter what your intent might be.

Attempting to discredit members here, attempting to discredit the Popular Mechanics editor, characterizing Garth's support of science and engineering as "total faith" -- all of this reeks of wanting to promote a particular agenda.

Dynometer testing will be the ultimate test, however one must know exactly what they are looking for in order to create an appropriate testing regime.

You are looking for a reduction of fuel flow with the unit turned on vs the unit turned off. Check at idle, 1/4 power, 1/2 power, 3/4 power, and full power. If, from this, there is any indication that there is a measurable change, then check at other power levels. Then collaborate with others and see if they can reproduce what you've found. Start with dyno testing, because with unsupervised road testing from all around the world, the scams only continue longer, and you give the impression to the naive that there is some "debate" about this in "scientific" circles... whereas of course there is not. If you believe I'm wrong, then present article references from the journals.

Present the data. Real data.

Register to Reply
Associate
Engineering Fields - Automotive Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Somewhere in the Pacifics...
Posts: 43
#125

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

09/23/2009 1:39 AM

OK... This is the raw data: Subject Vehicle: Honda TMX 155cc 4 stroke Date: September 18 - 19, 2009 Ambient Temperature: 34 deg. Centigrate (Fair weather/ Sunny/ a bit Humid) The Cell draws about 3A, HHO roughly about 0.1LPM, Bike is 12VDC system We just upgraded on the stator so as to keep the battery up. PUMP STATION: SHELL - Manila Fuel: Unleaded 93 Octane (same pump) Driving Style: Moderate and Random Driver: Ariel XXXX WITHOUT (September 18, 2009 - 10AM to 3PM) Route: Around Metro Manila START END TOTAL KM LITERS KPL NOTES 1. 2621.4/2636.2/ 14.8/ 0.605/ 24.46 2. 2636.2/2650.9/ 14.7/ 0.657/ 22.37 3. 2650.9/2665.5/ 14.6/ 0.751/ 19.44 4. 2665.5/2680.3/ 14.8/ 0.603/ 24.54 5. 2680.3/2695.2/ 14.9/ 0.572/ 26.05 WITH (September 19, 2009 - 10AM - 3PM) Route: Around Metro Manila 1. 2765.3/2780.3/ 15/ 0.648/ 23.15 2. 2780.3/2795.1/ 14.8/ 0.463/ 31.97 3. 2795.1/2809.9/ 14.8/ 0.534/ 27.72 4 2809.9/2824.7/ 14.8/ 0.9/ 16.44-Gasoline Attendant made Error in Filling up Tank (it turned out the pump wasn't reset to zero before refill) 5. 2824.7/2839.5/ 14.8/ 0.5/ 29.60 After discounting the 4th run figure due to the error made by the pump attendant, the following are the results. LOWEST MILEAGE: Without = 19.44 KPL WITH = 23.15 KPL HIGHEST MILEAGE GAINED: Without = 26.05 KPL WITH = 31.97 KPL AVERAGE MILEAGE: Without = 23.87 KPL WITH = 28.11 KPL NOTE: The driver/owner of the bike is an automotive technician and was very skeptic... He was biased about this thing and was reluctant or pessimistic about the effects of hho enhancement. He goes by the book in terms of engine tuning. He agreed to do the test runs just to have closure to an internal local debate... I leave the analysis to you. By the way; dont demand why we didnt make 10 runs for the baseline or the enhanced runs... each run was about 14km average - thats a long run!... and will probably only sip just above half a liter of fuel - it's not a walk in the park for any driver... what he did is just a favor so don't complain OK?

__________________
We are no better than the causes we are fighting for...
Register to Reply
Participant

Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 3
#126
In reply to #125

The Verdict - inconclusive

09/23/2009 10:04 PM

Firstly... as I think you already know, this is far from a sufficient amount of data to make any solid conclusions. However I have analysed the data you have given, and this is the result.

average kpl without HHO = 23.37 +/- 2.56 km/L

average kpl with HHO =28.11 +/- 3.74 km/L

Now the +/- component is the standard deviation of the data from the average value. This does not include any error carried from the original data (which there will be since all measured data has an associated error).Applying these errors would increase the +/- components.

The combined deviation (2.56 + 3.74 = 6.29) is larger than the difference in the two values (4.73), thus it is possible that the difference observed is simply the natural variation. This is where more values become useful, since the standard deviation usually decreases with more data points.

However the standard deviation of each value individually is smaller than the difference in the two values (2.56 and 3.74 compared to 4.73). This indicates that the is an improvement being made by the HHO, but this is far from conclusive.

There are also some anomalies in the data you provided. The values for the run without HHO follow a pattern that consistent with the temperature change through the times of each run (hotter temp mean more fuel is used due to lower efficiency). The run with HHO does not follow this pattern. This is most probably the result of other uncontrolled factors such as traffic, wind, etc. It may also be from differing rates HHO generation at different temps. Also the first run with HHO seems low compared to the others: maybe generator needed to warm up?

This is the problem with such experiments; there are too many uncontrolled variables. The only way to overcome this is lots of data points at DIFFERENT distances (min 3 at each distance and at least 10 different distances.)

Of course this is difficult to perform due to the time involved (I'm with you on that issue).

You have mentioned in previous posts that you have logged extensive data from you own vehicle during its daily use. Is this the case, do you have this data? This data would be most instructive as it would contain a wide range of distances and driving conditions. While this data probably has more variability, if there is sufficient data points this will not matter as much.

If you have such data then could you e-mail me the spreadsheet?

email to HHO.researcher@gmail.com

Include as much information as you can (the variables measured in the scooter test are sufficient but try to include as many notes as possible and reference to any modifications or maintenance to the car or HHO generator.

Register to Reply
Associate
Engineering Fields - Automotive Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Somewhere in the Pacifics...
Posts: 43
#127
In reply to #126

Re: The Verdict - inconclusive

09/23/2009 11:31 PM

ok - you got mail.

__________________
We are no better than the causes we are fighting for...
Register to Reply
Associate
Engineering Fields - Automotive Engineering - New Member

Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Somewhere in the Pacifics...
Posts: 43
#131
In reply to #126

Re: The Verdict - inconclusive

10/23/2009 5:38 AM

The scooter test runs where done on a specific route with very minimal traffic. All the runs were identical in nature in terms of ambient temperature, time, driver, speeds, etc. This is in order to minimize all variables. The pattern shows that without HHO or with the normal engine run mode, the efficiency increases as the engine warms up. With HHO, the engine actually does not run hotter, we have observed it to be running more cooler as it ran for the whole day - respectively speaking. With HHO, the efficiency shows an increasing or ascending line in favor of mileage gained. We are aware that there are too much variables in actual street run data... but we conducted these runs putting almost all the other variables into consideration so as to simulate a controlled conditions testing. This is the reason why a calibrated tank with graduations is used and we are strictly adhering to filling it up to the lower miniscus basis so we can have a more consistent condition. Hows your analysis on the file I sent you?...

__________________
We are no better than the causes we are fighting for...
Register to Reply
Guru

Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 4484
Good Answers: 247
#137

Re: Finally! A Great HHO test! (Run your car on water!)

11/18/2009 12:08 AM

Good news for putting this thread to bed:

Update: FTC puts Dennis Lee out of business.

It has been a long time coming, but Dennis Lee is now effectively out of the HHO business.* The FTC is continuing to work on further prosecution. Science 1, pseudo science 0. Dutchman is a Dennis Lee's company, and is the company which caused our guest Kip significant damage to his car.

There are loads of other scammers out there but Lee was one of the biggest. His HAFC used all the add-ons and widgets to help obscure the fact that none of it works. So no, it didn't work by catalytic effect, it certainly didn't work by fuel replacement, it didn't work by using an efie to "trick" the computer, it didn't work by adding just the right magic solvent. It just plain didn't work, despite using all the tricks that show up here at CR4 as explanations for why the scammer-du-jour device works.

Sadly he is not yet behind bars, so he can continue to promote his other perpetual motion machine, the Sundance generator and Hummingbird motor (search YouTube for all sorts of interesting videos -- some of them absolutely hilarious). But this is good work by the FTC and John Heywood, director of Sloan Automotive Lab at MIT. Testing was done at Compliance and Research Services Inc in New Jersey.

__________________
There is more to life than just eating mice.
Register to Reply Score 1 for Good Answer
Register to Reply Page 2 of 2: « First < Prev 1 2 Last »

Good Answers:

These comments received enough positive votes to make them "good answers".

"Almost" Good Answers:

Check out these comments that don't yet have enough votes to be "official" good answers and, if you agree with them, vote them!
Copy to Clipboard

Users who posted comments:

3Doug (1); Anonymous Poster (18); artbyjoe (1); Blink (15); BlueAussieBoy (1); BMan 18 (1); bob c (12); cwarner7_11 (4); DaveB (1); ehnriko (11); ffej (1); Garthh (28); Hendrik (1); HYdrobug (10); jin_evil22 (2); Joe.Bath (4); John Sensenig (8); Magichands65 (1); marcot (1); Neil Kwyrer (3); Nick McKenna (3); pantaz (1); Sparkstation (4); Tornado (1); TVP45 (2); YWROADRUNNER (4)

Previous in Forum: Energy   Next in Forum: Moving on over.... Rockin on over.....

Advertisement